Waikiki Eighteen: Missing a Deposit Deadline, an Illegal Short-Term Rental, and a Lockout Plan
Kimo is a salesperson at a firm that also manages rentals. He manages 18 long-term units in a Waikiki condominium for Hui LLC. Unit 7's tenant vacated August 31 and returned keys September 1: rent was $2,450, security deposit $2,450, plus a $300 'nonrefundable cleaning fee' and a $400 pet deposit. Kimo documents $1,900 of damage, intends to keep the cleaning fee and the entire pet deposit, and re-let the unit September 15 at $2,650. On September 2 he deposited all tenant funds into the firm's operating account 'to simplify bookkeeping' and has sent the tenant nothing. The owner now wants Unit 12 rented at a three-night minimum starting October 1; the house rules require rentals of at least 30 days, and the building is on Ala Wai Boulevard, outside any resort district. Unit 3 is seven days late on rent; Kimo plans to post a five-day notice and change the locks if it goes unpaid.
1. What must Kimo do with the Unit 7 money, and by when? Which deductions are defensible?
Read the worked answer
The clock has likely already run. Hawaii's residential landlord-tenant law requires the landlord to either refund the deposit or deliver a written, itemized statement of deductions with the balance within 14 days after the tenant surrenders possession. Keys returned September 1 means the deadline fell around mid-September. Missing it can forfeit the right to retain anything and expose the owner to the deposit plus costs and attorney's fees - a $2,850 problem turned into a much larger one.
Trust account, immediately. Tenant security and pet deposits are other people's money. Placing them in the firm's operating account is commingling, a serious violation of the license law and the Commission's rules, and it exposes both Kimo and the principal broker to discipline regardless of whether the tenant ever complains. Move the funds to the trust account today and reconstruct the ledger.
Deductions:
- The $1,900 in damage is recoverable only if documented by invoices, photos, and receipts, and only for damage beyond normal wear and tear. It cannot cover the owner's upgrades or re-letting costs.
- The $300 'nonrefundable cleaning fee' is a deposit in substance if it was collected to secure performance and is not tied to actual cleaning performed. A genuinely nonrefundable fee must be clearly identified as such in the rental agreement and must be reasonable.
- The $400 pet deposit can be applied only to documented pet-caused damage, not simply retained.
- The re-let at $2,650 on September 15 defeats any lost-rent claim, and the higher rent belongs to the owner - not to the deposit.
Kimo should issue the itemized statement and balance in the landlord's name, with written owner approval, and not decide contested amounts unilaterally.
2. Analyze the owner's plan for Unit 12. What are Kimo's options and exposure?
Read the worked answer
Three independent layers, and the plan fails all three.
1. The project documents. The declaration and bylaws define permitted unit use, and house rules adopted under Hawaii's condominium law are enforceable by the association - fines, injunctive relief, and, in a repeat-offender case, the association's costs. A 30-day minimum makes a three-night rental a violation on day one. Kimo must read the declaration, not just the house rules; some declarations prohibit transient occupancy outright and some units are restricted to residential use only.
2. County law. The City and County of Honolulu restricts transient vacation rentals to resort districts. Ala Wai Boulevard is not a resort district, so a three-night rental is unlawful, exposing the owner to daily fines. A pre-existing nonconforming use requires a specific certificate; there is none here.
3. The license and the management agreement. A licensee may not knowingly further an unlawful use. Kimo's duty is to analyze, advise in writing, and decline to implement. Collecting rents on an illegal transient rental can be treated as participating in it, and E&O coverage does not reach intentional illegality.
What to do: obtain the declaration, bylaws, and house rules; confirm county zoning in writing; deliver a written analysis to the owner; recommend a legal opinion; and decline to market or manage short-term rentals at this address. If the owner wants a lawful short-term product, ask about a resort-zoned building and check whether the arrangement fits Hawaii's time-share statute before marketing it as a plan.
3. Evaluate Kimo's notice-and-lockout plan for Unit 3.
Read the worked answer
Half right, half license-ending.
Right: a five-day written notice for nonpayment of rent is the correct first step under Hawaii's residential landlord-tenant law. But the notice must state the amount due and the consequence (termination if unpaid), be served by a permitted method, and be given the full five days - a tenant already seven days late does not shorten the notice period. Before serving it, confirm the lease's own notice terms and check whether any rent was accepted after the default, because accepting rent can waive the notice.
Wrong: changing the locks is a self-help eviction, and Hawaii does not permit it. The landlord faces damages and penalties, and the tenant may regain possession. Turning off utilities to force a move is the same mistake with the same exposure. The person who physically changes the lock may be personally exposed as well as the owner.
The correct sequence: five-day notice → if unpaid and unwaived, file a summary possession action in District Court → obtain judgment and a writ of possession → possession restored through the sheriff or police, not through a locksmith.
Kimo's role: manage the file, keep proof of service, document every communication, propose a written repayment plan if the owner agrees, and consider mediation. A licensee should never be the person who changes the lock on an occupied unit; that single act can cost him his license and the owner far more than the delinquent rent.