Declan's 12-Week Couch-to-5K
Declan is 54, works shifts as a warehouse supervisor, and has been told by his GP to 'lose weight and get moving'. He is 1.76 m tall and weighs 96 kg (BMI about 31.0), has hypertension controlled with bisoprolol, no chest pain, no known heart disease and no joint problems. His GP has cleared him for moderate-intensity exercise. He has not exercised since school and has joined a 12-week beginners' running group that meets twice a week, aiming to complete a 5 km fun run in June. At induction he says, 'just tell me what heart rate to train at - I read that 220 minus your age is your max.' He also asks whether he should buy a smartwatch. The group has a sports hall for wet evenings and a flat 1.5 km park loop with a bench every 400 m.
1. Explain why the 220-minus-age formula is a poor guide for Declan specifically, and state how you would actually set and monitor his intensity in the first month.
Read the worked answer
The formula: 220 − 54 gives a nominal maximum of 166 bpm, so a typical 60–70% band would be about 100–116 bpm. Two things make that misleading.
- The formula itself is imprecise. The error is roughly ±10–12 bpm, so his true maximum could be anywhere from about 145 to 190. Training to a number derived from it is guesswork dressed up as science.
- Bisoprolol changes the picture. A beta-blocker slows the heart and blunts the rate response to effort, so at any given workload his heart rate will be lower than predicted. A watch reading a comfortable-looking 108 bpm does not mean he is at 65% - he could be working considerably harder while the number flatters him.
What to use instead
- Talk test (primary): he should be able to speak a full sentence but not sing. If he can only manage a word or two, he is too hard.
- RPE, Borg 6–20: aim for 11–13, 'fairly light' to 'somewhat hard'. Ask him to rate after each interval and record it.
- Recovery: breathing should be back near normal within about a minute of stopping an interval.
Heart rate as trend, not target: once he has three weeks of data, use his own resting HR and the HR at which the talk test fails as personal reference points, and re-set them if his dose changes.
Smartwatch: useful for steps, pace and his own trend line; not a diagnostic tool, and not a reason to train to someone else's formula.
2. Design weeks 1–4 for him using the FITT principle and explain your progression rule, including how realistic a continuous 5 km is by week 12.
Read the worked answer
Frequency: three days a week - two supervised group sessions plus one solo walk. Rest days between running days, because at BMI 31 the load through knees and ankles is the limiting factor, not motivation.
Intensity: RPE 11–13, talk test positive. His first month is deliberately easy; the adaptation we want is tendon and habit, not fitness.
Time: week 1, 20–25 minutes of 1 minute jog / 2 minutes walk, repeated; week 2, 1:2 extended to 25–30 minutes; week 3, 2 minutes jog / 2 minutes walk; week 4, 3 minutes jog / 2 minutes walk for 30 minutes. The park loop with benches every 400 m is ideal - the walk breaks are built into the landscape, so nobody feels watched.
Type: walk–jog on flat, traffic-free ground, plus two 10-minute bodyweight strength sessions (sit-to-stand, wall press-ups, calf raises) to protect the joints that will complain later.
Progression rule: increase the jog duration before any increase in pace, and raise total weekly volume by no more than about 10% - if the Saturday session felt harder than RPE 13, repeat the week rather than advance.
Realism of 5 km by week 12: a continuous 5 km is plausible only if he is jogging 3 minutes comfortably by week 4; if not, target a 5 km run/walk in 40–45 minutes and say so early. He should also be nudged toward the 150 minutes a week guideline by walking on non-group days, so he is not dependent on two sessions.
3. Name the safety points you would build into the group's first month, including the red flags that end a session for him.
Read the worked answer
Before he starts
- GP clearance is on file, with the medication recorded; check whether the dose changes in the 12 weeks and re-issue guidance if it does.
- Well-fitted shoes, and a rule that nobody runs in fashion trainers.
- Confidentiality: the group does not need to know what he takes.
During sessions
- Warm-up of brisk walking and dynamic movement, not static stretching.
- Water available at the loop; in warm weather move to early morning and cut volume.
- Because he is on an antihypertensive, watch for light-headedness on standing after he stops - walk it off rather than sitting straight down.
- Cap running at three days a week; offer cycling or swimming as cross-training when his joints are sore, rather than pushing through.
Red flags that stop him immediately - chest pain or pressure, unusual breathlessness, dizziness or fainting, palpitations, or pain that alters his gait. Any of these means stop, sit, and get medical advice; chest pain means call 112/999.
Not a red flag, but a review point: if his RPE for the same session climbs over two weeks, or he is not recovering between sessions, reduce load rather than add a fourth day.