The Embankment Breach at 4 a.m.
On 14 August, after three days of heavy rain in the Kosi catchment, the embankment near a block in Supaul district breaches at 4 a.m. Twelve villages with about 9,000 people lie in the old Kosi course, the belt the river has shifted across before. The road to the block headquarters is under a metre of water, so the nearest NDRF team, 45 km away at the district headquarters, cannot drive in. The local police station has 22 constables, one inflatable boat whose outboard motor will not start, and two country boats with local boatmen. The SDM is away at the district headquarters. Relief material sits in a godown on the far side of the breach. By 6 a.m. several hundred villagers have gathered at the block office demanding relief, and a rumour is spreading that farmers on the other side deliberately cut the embankment.
1. Set out the constable's first three actions in the first hour and justify the order.
Read the worked answer
First, information before movement. The station sends a clear message to the SP, the control room, the DM and the BDO: time of breach, grid location, villages affected, road status, and the fact that the NDRF cannot approach by road. Without that message no boat, helicopter or medical team is released, and the SDM's absence makes it more urgent, not less. The DM as head of the district disaster management authority can pass directions to other departments under the Disaster Management Act, 2005, but only if he is told.
Second, life safety with the assets actually on hand. The two country boats with their own boatmen go to the villages already under water, carrying a constable and a rope per boat, with life jackets if they exist. The inflatable boat is not junk - with the motor dead it becomes a slow oared ferry for the cut-off hamlets. No constable is sent into moving water without a boatman who knows the current.
Third, secure the relief point and kill the rumour with facts. The godown is guarded before the queue turns into a scramble, and one designated officer speaks to the crowd, giving timings and route of the first relief boat. Rumours of deliberate cutting are exactly the kind that turn into a riot; they are answered by an official statement, not by argument.
2. With incomplete information, which villages do you evacuate first, and why should the boats not be split into singles?
Read the worked answer
Rank by four criteria, in this order: depth and rate of rise, whether the village is cut off with no high ground, the number of people who cannot move themselves - the elderly, infants, pregnant women, the injured - and the travel time from the launch point in a boat that is oared or poled.
The breach site and the villages immediately downstream of it come first, because current, not depth, kills; then the cut-off hamlets with no embankment to stand on; then villages that still have a dry link and can be moved on foot. A quick list written on paper, with a name against each village, is better than a perfect plan that arrives at noon.
The boats are not split into singles because there is no radio net, no second engine if one fails, and no one to pull a single boat out of a current. Two boats working as a pair can rescue each other; a lone boat becomes a second rescue problem. Each trip carries one constable, one boatman and a rope, and returns with the vulnerable first.
3. The crowd at the godown turns hostile. What legal and practical tools does the police party have, and what should not be done?
Read the worked answer
Legally, the district administration can impose restrictions and pass directions for relief distribution, and the Executive Magistrate or the police can act under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, which replaced the old Section 144 CrPC, to prohibit assembly in a specified area for a specified period where there is apprehension of danger. The police can also act against those who obstruct relief vehicles or damage public property, and can seize hoarded stock under the relevant control orders.
Practically, the tools that matter most are queue management: a single entry point, a token or line system, distribution to women-headed households first, and an announcement of the next distribution time so the crowd has a reason to disperse. A named officer speaks, everyone else stays silent, so the crowd hears one voice.
What should not be done: lathi-charging a flood-affected crowd, making arrests for shouting, giving unverified casualty or missing-person numbers to the press, or repeating the rumour even to deny it. A false claim about who cut the embankment, repeated by a policeman, becomes evidence in a future riot case.