Six People, One Open Pot and Four Bouts of Diarrhoea
Kamla's household in a north-Bihar village has six members: herself, her husband, two children aged 8 and 3 years, her mother-in-law and a disabled brother-in-law. The hand pump is 40 metres away. The family stores water in a wide-mouthed aluminium pot in the kitchen, uncovered, with a steel dipper that is also used to stir the drinking glass. There is no household latrine; the fields behind the house are used. The three-year-old has had four episodes of loose stools in the last six months, the most recent with blood-streaked mucus. Kamla wipes the child's face with the same cloth she uses on the kitchen platform. She says she is "too tired" to boil water and that the child "will outgrow it". A sub-centre is 3 km away; the ASHA visits once a month.
1. Trace the faecal-oral contamination routes in this household and rank three interventions, justifying the order.
Read the worked answer
Mapping the routes (the F-diagram): the source is open defecation in the fields. From there the organism travels by fluids (run-off and contaminated groundwater near the pump), fingers (no soap after defecation or after cleaning the child), flies (fields to kitchen), food (the platform cloth, the uncovered pot), and fields/feet (children playing barefoot where others defecate).
Within the house the water pot is the second critical point: the water may be safe at the pump, but a wide-mouthed, uncovered pot with one dipper used for the glass, for stirring and by hand re-contaminates it within hours.
Ranking and reasoning
- Stop the source - safe excreta disposal plus handwashing with soap at the five critical times. This breaks the largest number of transmission links and protects all six members at once; every other measure only filters contamination that the fields keep producing.
- Make the water chain safe - covered narrow-mouth pot with a tap or a reserved long-handled ladle, cleaned weekly and kept off the floor. Reason: contamination at the storage step can undo the benefit of boiling, so it is the highest-yield change the family can make this week with what it owns.
- Treat the water - boiling or chlorine tablets. Ranked third not because it is ineffective but because it is the step most likely to lapse when the mother is tired, and it does nothing about the fingers and flies that reach food directly. Note: the ranking is about which intervention removes the most contamination for the least effort, not about which is scientifically strongest in a laboratory.
2. Design a safe water chain from pump to mouth using what the family already owns, and state how the current diarrhoea episode should be managed at home, including referral signs.
Read the worked answer
The chain
- Draw water into a container used only for drinking water; never use it for washing hands or utensils.
- Let it stand and settle, then boil to a rolling boil for 1–2 minutes (or add one chlorine tablet per the packet strength, wait 30 minutes). Store only in a narrow-mouthed pot with a lid, placed on a stand, not on the floor.
- Keep one reserved long-handled ladle; it must not touch the mouth, fingers or the glass rim. Never dip a glass into the pot.
- Scrub the pot weekly with ash or soap and dry it in the sun.
- Reason for each rule: the aim is to break contact between the stored water and hands, dust, flies and utensils, because a safe source is spoiled at the storage step.
Managing the current episode
- Low-osmolarity ORS, one full sachet in 1 litre of safe water, given in small sips after every loose stool - roughly 50–100 mL per stool for a 3-year-old. Discard mixed ORS after 24 hours.
- Zinc for 14 days (20 mg a day for a child above 6 months) - this shortens the episode and reduces recurrence over the next few months.
- Continue feeding and breastfeeding-equivalent soft food; do not starve the child or stop feeds.
- Refer without delay if there is blood in the stool (as now), sunken eyes, not drinking, vomiting everything, high fever, no urine for many hours, or diarrhoea lasting beyond 7 days.
3. The presence of blood-streaked mucus changes the picture. Explain what it indicates and how the household advice must change.
Read the worked answer
What it indicates: blood and mucus in loose stools mean the infection is invasive and has inflamed the lower bowel - this is dysentery, not simple watery diarrhoea. The common bacterial cause is Shigella; amoebic dysentery and giardiasis are also possible in a setting with unsafe water. A 3-year-old with four episodes in six months plus blood now is a child with recurrent enteric infection and probable growth risk.
How the advice changes
- This is a referral case, not a home-management case. ORS and zinc are still given on the way - ORS prevents the dehydration that kills - but they do not treat the invasive organism, and an antibiotic decision belongs to a clinician.
- Do not give anti-motility or 'stopper' medicines. Slowing the gut keeps the organism and toxins inside and can worsen the illness.
- Ask for a stool examination at the sub-centre, and add a weight record at each ASHA visit; falling weight on the growth chart converts this from a series of episodes into a malnutrition risk that must be tracked.
- The mother's belief that the child "will outgrow it" must be answered with the household's own evidence: four episodes in six months is not growing out of anything, and the same water pot and same wiping cloth keep re-infecting the child. Correcting the water chain and the cloth use is now part of clinical management, not an optional extra.