The theka that added a matra
A candidate submits a handwritten theka for internal assessment. The heading says “Jhaptal - 10 matras”. The notation reads: 1 dhi, 2 na, 3 dhi, 4 dhi, 5 na, 6 ti, 7 na, 8 dhi, 9 dhi, 10 na, and then an extra “dhi” crowded after 10 with no matra number. Above the matras the candidate has written vibhag marks after 2, 5, 7 and 10, and marked “0” over matra 3, “2” over matra 6, and “3” over matra 8. The teacher's comment says only “check tali/khali and avartan”. The candidate insists the extra dhi is the sam of the next avartan and should be counted. In the viva, the examiner asks him to clap the theka and then read it aloud in a continuous avartan.
1. Is the extra “dhi” an error? Identify the taal, its matra count and vibhag structure, and separate the real errors from the candidate's misunderstanding.
Read the worked answer
The extra “dhi” is not an eleventh matra. It is the sam of the next avartan, and the candidate is right that it should be shown as the beginning of a new cycle, but wrong to number or count it inside the ten-matra Jhaptal. Jhaptal has 10 matras in four vibhags of 2 + 3 + 2 + 3. The bol sequence dhi na | dhi dhi na | ti na | dhi dhi na is correct. The vibhag marks after 2, 5, 7 and 10 are also correct. The real errors are the tali/khali marks: matra 1 is sam (X), matra 3 is tali (2), matra 6 is khali (0), and matra 8 is tali (3). The candidate has put 0 on 3 and 2 on 6, which reverses the khali and the first tali. The extra dhi should be written after a double bar as the next sam, not squeezed into the same avartan.
2. Rewrite the notation correctly, showing sam, tali, khali, vibhag and the avartan boundary.
Read the worked answer
A correct presentation is:
Jhaptal - 10 matras (2 + 3 + 2 + 3)
| Matra | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bol | dhi | na | dhi | dhi | na | ti | na | dhi | dhi | na |
| Mark | X | 2 | 0 | 3 |
The vibhag divisions fall after matras 2, 5, 7 and 10. Sam is matra 1 and must be shown with X; tali 2 is on matra 3, khali 0 is on matra 6, and tali 3 is on matra 8. The next avartan begins with a new sam dhi after a double bar:
|| dhi na | dhi dhi na | ti na | dhi dhi na ||
The candidate's bols are mostly right; the marking must be corrected, and the extra dhi must be placed outside the ten-matra cycle. This distinction matters because an examiner reading the notation will count ten matras, not eleven.
3. How should the candidate self-check the notation by clapping and reciting, and what should he listen for?
Read the worked answer
He should recite the theka in a continuous loop while clapping the vibhags. Clap firmly on sam (1) and on the talis at 3 and 8; on khali (6) keep the hand open or wave rather than clap. Count 1 2 | 3 4 5 | 6 7 | 8 9 10 so the unequal vibhags are felt. At the end of matra 10, do not add a counted beat; the next dhi is the new sam and should feel like a fresh start. A useful check is to recite only the marks: X - 2 - 0 - 3 - X. If the candidate claps on 3 as khali, the error becomes audible immediately. He should also write one full avartan with a double bar and a second sam, then read it aloud without stopping. The test is whether a listener can hear where the cycle begins, not whether the page looks tidy.