Tunnel Collapse: Who Gets Requisitioned First
A cloudburst at 03:40 floods an under-construction hydro tunnel in a hill district, trapping 41 workers about 180 metres inside. The District Magistrate reaches the site at 05:10 and finds that the district police control room has only 60 personnel trained in rope rescue. The nearest NDRF battalion is at a town 240 km away, and its commanding officer says the unit can move in 90 minutes. A CAPF battalion of 800 personnel is camped 35 km away on law-and-order duty; its commandant offers men and earth-moving equipment but says he cannot move without written authority. Local volunteers have begun digging with hand tools, and a crowd of about 2,000 has gathered on the only approach road. The DM must decide who is requisitioned first, under what legal power, and how the decision is recorded. The state emergency operations centre asks for a written justification within two hours.
1. Under what authority can the DM requisition private excavators, trucks and generators, and was the CAPF commandant right to refuse to move?
Read the worked answer
The DM acts as chairperson of the District Disaster Management Authority under the Disaster Management Act, 2005, and that Authority is empowered to requisition resources, vehicles, premises and equipment for disaster response. The excavators, tippers, generators and lighting towers can therefore be commandeered by written order, with a receipt to the owner, an inventory, a stated period, and compensation assessed under the state's norms. Two limits apply: the requisition must be for the response and for a stated duration, and it does not extend to commandeering central armed police or NDRF personnel, who move on their own chains of command. The commandant was therefore correct - a unit deployed for law and order cannot convert itself into a disaster relief force on the spot. The DM should issue requisition orders for private plant immediately and route the CAPF and NDRF requests through the state government.
2. Set out the order of operations from 05:10, with reasons for each step.
Read the worked answer
Priority is set by capability and time, not by rank. First, 05:10 to 05:40: district police, fire service and volunteers continue rope rescue, and the DM signs requisition orders for two private excavators and lighting towers. Second, simultaneously, the SEOC is alerted and a formal NDRF request is sent, stating the 240 km move and 90-minute mobilisation, which puts earliest arrival near 10:00. Third, the CAPF request is routed to the state government and MHA for sanction; meanwhile the 800 men already camped 35 km away can cordon the 2,000-strong crowd and keep the approach road clear, once the district police make a written request for aid to civil power. Fourth, medical teams are staged and a helipad marked. The error to avoid is idling until the NDRF arrives: the first hour of local digging decides survival, and the road must be clear for the excavators that do arrive.
3. What should the two-hour written justification contain, and why does it matter beyond paperwork?
Read the worked answer
It should carry a timeline (cloudburst 03:40, DM on site 05:10, requisitions 05:40), the number trapped and the depth, the resources held, requested and their expected arrival, the legal basis for each requisition, the crowd and traffic measures, and the specific reason NDRF specialists were sought - confined-space and tunnel rescue beyond district capability. It should also record refusals and dissents, such as the commandant's position, so that blame does not later attach to a lawful refusal. Costs should be estimated and certified. The record protects the DM against allegations of inaction and against claims of unlawful requisition, and it gives the SEOC what it needs to escalate to the NDMA. Short contemporaneous entries in the district disaster log are worth more than a polished report written after the event, when memories have aligned with reputations.