Twelve Desks, One Hall
The office of a government vocational training institute in Bhubaneswar has twelve staff in a single hall of 9 m by 6 m. Desks are arranged wherever space was available when each person joined. One clerk sits with her back to the only door and is in direct draught whenever it opens. The photocopier and printer stand beside the accounts clerk, who handles cash and vouchers. Four visitor chairs are placed at the far end of the hall, so every visitor walks past all twelve desks to reach them. The supervisor's table is in the middle and is used for confidential counselling of trainees. Two windows on one side give the only daylight, and staff complain of afternoon glare on their screens and of fatigue by 4 p.m. The institute can release Rs 60,000 for furniture and minor electrical work this financial year, and the hall cannot be extended.
1. Propose a layout for the hall, explaining the reasoning for each placement decision.
Read the worked answer
The governing principle is to arrange the hall by work rather than by who arrived first. Four decisions follow.
Supervisor at a rear corner, facing the door. This gives a sightline over the whole hall, which a central table does not, and removes the counselling function from the middle of the room. A low partition beside the table creates a confidential corner for trainee counselling at modest cost, which is the only realistic way to hold private discussions in a shared hall.
Visitor zone near the entrance. Move the four chairs and a small table to the area immediately inside the door, and leave a clear 90 cm path from door to visitor zone. Visitors then stop at the edge of the office instead of crossing twelve desks, which reduces disturbance and removes an easy route to unattended papers.
Accounts clerk and cash away from the machines, close to the strong room. The printer beside cash and vouchers is a security and accuracy risk: visitors approach that desk, and noise breaks concentration on figures. Group accounts with the cash chest, with a clear view from the supervisor.
Relocate the doorway clerk. Move her desk to an internal position and place a small screen or cabinet to break the draught. Do not leave a desk in the door swing merely because it has always been there.
2. Which low-cost changes genuinely address the glare and fatigue complaints, and which would be a waste of the budget?
Read the worked answer
The complaints have more than one cause, and a single purchase will not fix them.
Glare. Daylight comes from one side only. The effective, cheap remedy is to turn desks so that screens sit perpendicular to the windows, not facing or backing them, and to fit curtains or roller blinds on the window side. Both cost little. Buying anti-glare screens for twelve workstations would consume a large part of Rs 60,000 while leaving the underlying arrangement unchanged, so it is poor value as a first step.
Fatigue by 4 p.m. Candidates here are draught from the door, noise from the photocopier, poor seating, and stale air in a 54 sq m hall with windows on one side. A screen at the door, relocation of the printer, and an exhaust fan or fan placement to move air are all within budget and address identifiable causes. New chairs may help, but only after the arrangement is corrected, otherwise the office spends money and the complaint returns.
What would be a waste: blocking one of the two windows with a cupboard to gain wall space, or fitting heavy partitions that cut the only cross-ventilation. Both would visibly 'solve' the layout problem while making the air and light worse, which is the opposite of what staff are reporting.
3. The accounts clerk says the photocopier should stay beside her because it is convenient. Evaluate this request.
Read the worked answer
Convenience for one person is a weak justification when the same position creates three risks.
Security. The accounts clerk handles cash and vouchers. Placing a shared machine beside her means staff and visitors approach that desk repeatedly through the day, which is precisely the traffic a cash-handling position should not attract.
Accuracy. Interruptions while posting figures are a recognised source of error, and the mistake may surface only at audit, long after the interruption is forgotten.
Noise and fumes. Printer and copier noise beside a desk working on figures undermines the concentration the same clerk needs, and toner dust in a closed hall with windows on one side is undesirable.
The right response is not simply to refuse. Identify a position that is still reasonably accessible, such as an alcove near the entrance, so the walk is short for everyone; keep the machine out of the visitor route and away from cash. If usage is heavy, add a simple counter or log sheet per section so that running costs and machine faults can be attributed. The clerk's real concern may be frequent walking, and a compromise position near the entrance answers it without putting a shared machine in the cash corner.