Opioid Request, INSPECT Red Flags, and a Bad Review
Dr. Simone Whitfield practices in South Bend. A 32-year-old man presents with severe pain from tooth #30. He demands "Norco 10" and says, "Hydrocodone doesn't work for me." He reports no medical conditions and no other medications. The Indiana prescription monitoring program report shows two opioid prescriptions in the past 30 days from an urgent care clinic and an active benzodiazepine prescription from a psychiatrist. The patient says the report is "wrong" and denies taking anything else. Dr. Whitfield has not yet performed pulp vitality testing or taken a periapical radiograph. She is concerned about a negative online review and writes a prescription for 30 hydrocodone/acetaminophen tablets with one refill. She does not document the INSPECT report or a risk discussion. The patient leaves happy.
1. Identify the prescribing and clinical problems in this encounter and explain what Dr. Whitfield should have done before issuing any prescription.
Read the worked answer
The encounter has clinical and regulatory gaps. First, she prescribed without diagnosing the source of pain: no pulp vitality testing, no periapical image, and no clear treatment plan. Second, the INSPECT report shows overlapping opioid prescriptions and an active benzodiazepine, which is a serious sedation and respiratory-depression risk; the patient's denial does not erase the report. Third, 30 tablets with a refill is a large quantity for acute dental pain, and the refill compounds the risk. Fourth, she documented neither the PMP review nor a risk discussion. Before prescribing, she should examine and image the tooth, diagnose pulpal/periapical status, query INSPECT as required, review the report, and attempt to contact the other prescribers with appropriate consent or at least document the attempts. She should consider source control-pulpectomy or extraction-and non-opioid analgesia. If an opioid is truly necessary, she should use the lowest effective dose, a short supply, no refill, and document the rationale and warnings.
2. What non-opioid and procedural alternatives should she consider, and what must be documented if she decides to prescribe an opioid?
Read the worked answer
Alternatives include local anesthesia, pulpectomy or extraction for source control, and a scheduled nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug such as ibuprofen when not contraindicated, often combined with acetaminophen. Antibiotics are not analgesics and should be used only for a genuine infection indication. If an opioid is prescribed, the record should show the diagnosis, the PMP review, the other controlled substances identified, the risk discussion, the quantity and dose, the absence of refills, and the plan for follow-up. She should warn about sedation, driving, alcohol, and combining the opioid with benzodiazepines, and consider naloxone education where appropriate. She should also document why alternatives were insufficient. A note that says only "Norco given" does not demonstrate the required judgment. If the patient refuses source control, that refusal should be documented, along with the risks of delay.
3. How should Dr. Whitfield respond to the patient's demand and the fear of a negative online review?
Read the worked answer
The threat of a bad review is not a clinical indication and cannot justify inappropriate prescribing. She should respond professionally, acknowledge the patient's pain, explain that she needs to examine and image the tooth, and offer source control and non-opioid options. If the patient becomes abusive or refuses necessary care, she may set boundaries, document the interaction, and arrange emergency coverage or transfer rather than abandon him. She should not retaliate by dismissing him mid-emergency without notice and records. If a negative review appears, she should not disclose protected health information in any public response. The Board's concern is patient safety and sound prescribing, not online reputation. Documenting the refusal and the alternatives offered protects both the patient and the practice.