Green Nail Versus a Dark Longitudinal Band
Marcus, 38, arrives for a manicure before a job interview. On the right middle finger the nail plate is lifted about 40% from the distal edge, and the exposed nail bed is stained dark green-black with a musty odor. The lateral fold is mildly red and warm but not swollen. On the left thumb a 1 mm wide dark brown band runs from cuticle to free edge; it has widened over eight months, and pigment extends onto the proximal nail fold. Marcus says he slammed the right finger in a car door two months ago and has been covering the discoloration with polish. He asks you to 'clean out the green stuff, file it down, and put on a hard gel overlay so it looks normal' before Saturday. He has no primary care doctor and no insurance. The salon has a UV gel lamp, an e-file, and a jar of clear acrylic.
1. Differentiate the two nail presentations. Which, if either, may you treat today, and why?
Read the worked answer
The right middle finger is a classic bacterial colonization under a lifted plate: green-black stain, musty odor, and onycholysis after trauma. The green pigment is likely Pseudomonas, not a mold or fungus, and it is not treatable with polish, filing, or salon antiseptics. Because the nail bed is exposed and the fold is warm and red, there may be early paronychia; applying gel would trap moisture and bacteria. The left thumb is more concerning: a dark longitudinal band that has widened over eight months, plus pigment on the proximal fold, is a red flag for subungual melanoma. That is not a cosmetic issue and cannot wait. I would treat neither. I would not thin, curette, or cover either nail. I would explain the difference in plain language, avoid diagnosing, and refer the thumb urgently to a dermatologist and the finger to a physician. I would document the size, location, and date of observation, and note that no service was performed.
2. What steps do you take after the consultation, including documentation and disinfection?
Read the worked answer
First, stop and do not apply product. I would photograph only with written consent and per salon policy; otherwise measure and describe. I would write a factual note: what I saw, size, color, odor, duration, the client's request, my referral, and his response. I would give him a written referral list and tell him not to cover the thumb with polish. I would not use the e-file on either nail; if any tool touched the green nail, it would be cleaned and disinfected as a contaminated item, and files would be discarded. The table, lamp, and cushion get an EPA-registered disinfectant. I would wash my hands before and after glove removal. I would reschedule only after medical clearance, and I would not share his information with the next client. If he refuses referral, I document that I explained the risk and declined service.
3. Marcus says he cannot afford a doctor and begs you to cover the nails for the interview. How do you handle the ethical and communication challenge?
Read the worked answer
I would acknowledge the pressure without minimizing the risk. Covering a suspect melanoma delays diagnosis; covering a bacterial nail can worsen infection. I would say clearly that I am not able to diagnose, but the changes need a medical opinion, and that a salon service would not be safe or honest. I can offer practical help: a list of low-cost clinics, a clean and shape of the unaffected nails, and a matte buff on the healthy nails if no product touches the affected ones. I would avoid shaming him. If he asks me to just 'do it anyway,' I decline and document. I would not accept a waiver. I would keep the conversation confidential and give him space to decide. The goal is a safe outcome and a referral he can act on, not a sale.