Six Issues, Sixty Customers and One Shift in Charge
It is 8:30 pm on the Friday before Deepavali at a 2,500 sq ft supermarket in Belagavi. The owner is on a call and the supervisor is on leave; you are the shift in-charge. You notice five things. Six cartons of soft drinks are stacked in front of the rear fire exit, which is also the staff route to the washroom. Thirty-four packets of a namkeen brand sit on the shelf with a best-before date of last month, clearly printed. The weighing scale at the loose-grains counter carries a verification sticker dated 14 months ago. A 16-year-old, the son of the cleaning staff, is helping bag groceries at the counter because of the rush. At counter 2, a customer insists on a 'no bill' discount on a ₹4,200 pressure cooker if he pays cash. There are three billing counters and about 60 customers inside.
1. Rank the five issues by the harm each can cause in the next two hours and in the next two weeks, and state the first action for each.
Read the worked answer
Rank by immediacy of harm, not by paperwork size.
- Blocked fire exit (act now, within minutes). Sixty customers, a holiday crowd and a stack of cartons on the only rear escape route: a panic or a small fire becomes a crush injury. First action: move all six cartons personally or with a helper, clear the route, check the door opens freely, and keep it clear for the evening. Life safety outranks every commercial consideration.
- 16-year-old at the counter (act now). He is an adolescent, and any employment is permitted only in non-hazardous work with regulated hours, written consent and records; there is no record here and he is handling cash late at night. First action: thank him, move him off the counter and out of the work area, and later put the arrangement on a proper footing or end it. Verify the applicable Karnataka rules before any future engagement.
- Expired namkeen (act now, takes ten minutes). Thirty-four packets of unsafe food on open sale create illness risk and an FSS Act penalty. First action: pull all 34 plus any same-batch back stock, tag them 'not for sale', and record the withdrawal.
- Weighing scale sticker 14 months old (act before the next inspection). Verification is valid for 12 months; an unverified scale breaches the Legal Metrology Act and undermines every loose-grain sale. First action: stop using it, switch to a calibrated spare, and book re-verification.
- No-bill cash deal (act at the counter). Refuse politely; it is tax evasion and puts the licence at risk. First action: one clear refusal with a legitimate alternative.
Then log each item with time and action, and inform the owner the same night - the supervisor's absence does not transfer the legal duty.
2. Describe the exact sequence for the expired namkeen, from shelf to disposal, and the records you would keep.
Read the worked answer
Sequence:
- Withdraw: remove all 34 packets and check the back stock, adjacent facings and any secondary display for the same batch.
- Segregate: place them in a closed crate marked 'EXPIRED - NOT FOR SALE' in the returns area, physically away from saleable stock. Never leave them on a shelf with a discount sticker.
- Count and record: enter in the expiry and damage register - product, brand, batch or lot number, MRP, quantity (34), date pulled, reason, name and signature of the person pulling and of a second verifier.
- Inform and decide: notify the owner the same night; contact the distributor for a replacement or credit note while the return window is open, and raise a debit note if credit is agreed.
- Dispose: if return is refused, destroy so the product cannot re-enter sale - open the packets, mix with waste, and record date, method, quantity and a witness; keep a photograph and the destruction entry. Follow municipal waste rules.
- Root cause: check why the date was missed - no date check at goods receipt, no FEFO rotation, no weekly shelf audit. Fix by checking dates at GRN, tagging stock with 30 days or less remaining, and a weekly shelf-life walk with a signed sheet.
Records to retain: expiry register extract, distributor debit note or credit note, destruction record with witness, and the corrective action note. These are what an inspector or an audit will ask for.
3. How would you refuse the no-bill cash deal without losing the customer, and what does the store's legal position require?
Read the worked answer
Legal position first: GST law requires a tax invoice for every taxable supply. A 'no bill' price is an offer to suppress turnover: the store loses input tax credit, the sale becomes unaccounted income, and penalties under the CGST Act can equal the tax evaded or ₹10,000, whichever is higher, with prosecution risk for repetition. No cashier or shift in-charge has authority to accept it, and a ₹4,200 pressure cooker is not a rounding error - the tax alone is material. Pressure cookers are also under compulsory BIS certification, so check the ISI mark before selling at all.
How to refuse:
- Do not moralise or mention tax evasion. Make the answer mechanical: 'Sir, the price is the same in cash, card or UPI, and the bill prints automatically.'
- Sell the benefit to him: the bill is his warranty and exchange proof, and the ₹4,200 already includes GST.
- Offer a legitimate lever: an authorised festive discount within your written limit, a free accessory, or help with UPI if that is his real concern. Often the 'no bill' request is about a discount, not about the bill.
- Hold the line calmly: if he threatens to leave, let him. One lost sale is cheaper than a suppression finding and a cancelled licence.
- Escalate and record: call the owner if he becomes abusive, and note the incident in the shift log.
The test is whether the store can produce a bill for every rupee that left the counter. Anything else is a decision the owner must make in writing, not a cashier at 8:30 pm.