Maharashtra HSC Russian (MSBSHSE) study materials
Maharashtra HSC Russian (MSBSHSE) study resources

Reading: deciding what «сдал» means without a teacher

Maharashtra HSC Russian (MSBSHSE) · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

Reading: deciding what «сдал» means without a teacher

Anil, a Std XII student from Kolhapur who studies Russian through Hindi, is practising a 220-word passage about a school trip to Moscow. The text contains the sentence «Утром мы сдали рюкзаки в камеру хранения и пошли к автобусу». Anil knows сдавать/сдать only from the classroom phrase сдавать экзамен, so he reads the sentence as 'we passed the rucksacks' and the rest of the paragraph stops making sense. His pocket dictionary lists three meanings for сдать: to hand in; to pass (an exam); to rent out. He has 90 seconds left for this item and two comprehension questions still to answer. A second sentence reads «Экскурсия была отменена, но мы не расстроились: мы пошли в кафе». Anil does not know отменена or расстроились. He may use the dictionary but may not ask the teacher.

1. Which dictionary meaning of сдать fits this sentence, and which words decide the choice? Show the elimination, not only the answer.

Read the worked answer

Eliminate by the object noun. 'To pass an exam' needs an exam word as object - экзамен, зачёт, тест. Here the object is рюкзаки, so this reading is impossible. 'To rent out' needs a property or item given to a tenant or client, usually with кому-либо, and a commercial context; neither is present.

What remains. 'To hand in' is the only meaning compatible with рюкзаки plus the place phrase в камеру хранения (left-luggage office). Grammar supports it: сдать is perfective, so the sentence reports one completed act, and the prefix с- adds the idea of 'away, off'.

Translation: 'In the morning we handed in our rucksacks at the left-luggage office and went to the bus.'

The exam point is that the first dictionary meaning is not automatically the right one: the noun after the verb controls the choice.

2. How can Anil recover the sense of отменена and расстроились without a dictionary, and how should he spend the remaining 90 seconds?

Read the worked answer

Use the contrast and the consequence. The clause after «но» says «мы пошли в кафе» - the plan changed and the pupils did something else instead. So отменена must mean 'cancelled'; the short participle ending -ена and the root отмен- point to the verb отменить. For расстроились, the reflexive -ся and the prefix рас- are typical of emotional verbs, and the following action (they went to a café) shows the emotion was not negative: 'we were not upset'.

Write a bracket meaning and move on. Anil should pencil 'cancelled' and 'upset' above the words, not stop to parse every letter. With 90 seconds left, he should answer the global questions first - 'why did the pupils go to a café?' - because the main idea is clear without full morphological analysis. If a question depends on one unknown word, he can return to it after the easier items.

3. Anil is tempted to write 'we passed the rucksacks' because it uses a real meaning of сдать. Explain why this would still lose marks.

Read the worked answer

A real meaning is not the same as a possible collocation. English 'pass' with a physical object does not mean 'hand in', so the sentence becomes nonsense in the target language even though the dictionary entry is genuine. In Russian, сдать рюкзаки в камеру хранения is a normal action; сдать экзамен is also normal; the two are distinguished by the object and the place phrase, not by the verb alone.

A marker awards comprehension marks for the meaning of the sentence, not for finding a dictionary match. The safe procedure is: identify the object, identify the prepositional phrase, then select the meaning that makes both fit. If no meaning fits, the student should re-read the whole paragraph before writing.