Oversold Weekend at a 42-Room Hill Hotel
Hotel Sahyadri is a 42-room property in Mahabaleshwar. On a Saturday in December, the night auditor's report shows 44 confirmed arrivals against 42 sellable rooms; two rooms are out of order because of a failed water pump on the third floor. The channel manager has oversold after a rate update. Among the 44 arrivals are a wedding block of 18 rooms under a signed contract with a ₹50,000 advance; Mr. and Mrs. Deshpande, direct-booking repeat guests on their 12th stay, holding a confirmed reservation with a ₹1,000 token; 14 prepaid non-refundable OTA bookings; and two walk-in bookings made by phone yesterday without guarantee. The wedding coordinator calls at 14:00 to say the baraat will arrive at 16:00 and needs early check-in for two rooms. The front office manager is on leave and the duty manager is a newly promoted shift supervisor.
1. Rank the four arrival groups by the strength of the hotel's obligation and decide which two rooms should be relocated. Explain the reasoning.
Read the worked answer
The strongest obligation is the wedding block: it is a signed contract with a ₹50,000 advance and an event dependent on the rooms. Next are the 14 prepaid non-refundable OTA bookings: the hotel has taken money and issued a confirmation, so walking them creates a refund, commission and review problem. Next is Mr. Deshpande, a direct repeat guest on his 12th stay with a confirmed reservation; he is not legally stronger than a prepaid OTA booking, but he is commercially valuable and should not be the first person walked. Weakest are the two phone bookings made yesterday without guarantee: no deposit, no prepaid amount, and no contractual guarantee beyond a courtesy hold.
Therefore the two unguaranteed phone bookings should be relocated if they have not arrived. If they have already arrived, the duty manager should still choose them, but must handle the situation personally and with compensation. The hotel should not break the wedding contract or surprise the repeat guest at the desk. The decision is based on contractual strength, money already taken, event dependence and the cost of recovery, not on who is easiest to move.
2. Draft the relocation protocol the duty manager should follow, including what to say, transport, payment and compensation.
Read the worked answer
The duty manager should call the two unguaranteed guests before they reach the hotel if possible. The message should be honest and specific: 'We have an inventory error and cannot provide the room you booked. We have arranged a comparable room at [partner hotel], and the hotel will pay for your taxi and the room difference.' The duty manager should not blame the channel manager or the guest. At the desk, the guest should be given a written note with the partner hotel's name, address, contact number and the name of the person handling the booking. The hotel should pay the taxi directly or reimburse against a receipt, settle the partner hotel's room charge, and offer dinner or a future-stay voucher as a goodwill gesture.
If the guest refuses, the duty manager should escalate to the front office manager or general manager rather than argue. The incident should be logged with the guest's name, booking source, time of notification, compensation given and the partner hotel used. The rationale is that an unguaranteed booking can be relocated, but the guest must not be left to solve the problem alone. Compensation is cheaper than a public complaint and protects the hotel's reputation in a peak weekend market.
3. What should the duty manager tell the wedding coordinator about early check-in, and what system changes would prevent a repeat?
Read the worked answer
The duty manager should not promise all 18 rooms early. The honest answer is: 'Two rooms will be ready by 13:30 for the baraat party, and the remaining rooms will be ready by the standard check-in time. We will hold luggage and serve welcome drinks in the lobby.' The two rooms should be selected from clean vacant rooms or the first checkout rooms cleaned, and the housekeeping supervisor should be told which room numbers are needed. If the two rooms cannot be ready, the duty manager must call the coordinator before 13:00, not wait for the baraat to arrive.
Prevention requires an inventory buffer and daily overbooking limit, removal of out-of-order rooms from all channels, and a channel-manager sync check before the weekend. The hotel should also adopt a written walk-in policy: phone bookings without a guarantee are held only until a stated time. A 10-minute morning huddle between front office and housekeeping should compare arrivals, departures and blocked rooms. The root cause here is a rate update that changed availability without a human check, so the fix is a process control, not a reminder to the staff to be careful.