Applying a Notice-Writing Rubric to Two Student Scripts
A five-mark notice-writing task is set: 'Your school's lost-and-found box has many unclaimed items. Write a notice for the school notice board asking students to claim their items before Friday.' The rubric is format 2 (heading, date, signature or designation), content 2, language 1. Student A writes: 'LOST AND FOUND. I have lost my blue water bottle. If anyone finds it, please give it to me. I am very sad. - Rohan, Class 10-B, 12 July.' Student B writes: 'NOTICE. All students are informed that unclaimed items in the lost-and-found box will be disposed of on Friday. Claim your items from the office before 4 p.m. - Cultural Secretary, 12 July.' Student A has a heading, a date and a name, but the purpose is personal loss rather than a general announcement. Student B has a heading, a date and a designation, but uses slightly threatening language ('disposed of'). The teacher must mark both scripts consistently and decide whether Student B's tone should cost a language mark. The class has 42 students, and the teacher wants to display one script as a model.
1. Apply the rubric to Student A and Student B. Give marks out of 5 and justify each component.
Read the worked answer
Student A: 2/5. Format 1: heading, date and name are present, but there is no designation and the heading is misleading ('LOST AND FOUND' for a personal loss). Content 0: the task is a general notice asking students to claim unclaimed items; A writes about one lost bottle. Language 1: the message is understandable, but 'I am very sad' is informal and self-focused. Total 1+0+1=2. Student B: 5/5. Format 2: heading, date and designation are present. Content 2: purpose, audience, deadline and action are clear. Language 1: formal and concise. 'Disposed of' is firm but appropriate for unclaimed property; it is not abusive. If the school rubric treats tone as part of language, I would still award 1 because the register is formal and the consequence is stated factually. Consistency matters: A loses content marks for wrong purpose, not for being informal alone.
2. Rewrite Student A's notice in the correct register in under 45 words.
Read the worked answer
Model rewrite (under 45 words): 'NOTICE. Unclaimed items in the school lost-and-found box will be removed after Friday. Students should claim their belongings from the office before 4 p.m. - Head Boy/Head Girl, 12 July.' This keeps the heading, date and designation, states the action and deadline, and uses third person. It does not mention Rohan's bottle because the notice is for the whole school.
3. What is the difference between a notice and a letter, and which words in Student A's script reveal the confusion?
Read the worked answer
Difference: a notice is a public, impersonal announcement to a group; a letter is addressed to a specific person and often uses first/second person. Student A reveals the confusion with 'I have lost', 'give it to me' and 'I am very sad' - all letter-like, personal expressions. A notice would say 'Students who have lost items should...' The purpose is also different: A reports one loss; the task asks the school community to claim many items.