Chanting English but not answering it
A Std 4 class of 38 in a municipal school in Nagpur has English four periods a week, 35 minutes each. The teacher's routine is: write six words on the board, read them, the class repeats three times, then every child copies each word five times. The first unit test (30 marks: 10 spellings, 10 fill-in-the-blanks, 10 matching) left 23 children below 10 marks. The children chant 'Good morning, how are you?' perfectly when the teacher enters, but when she asks 'Are you hungry?' just before the midday meal, nobody answers. Shown a picture of a boy drinking water and asked 'What is he doing?', Rani says 'Water' and stops. Most children are first-generation learners with no English outside school. The head teacher says the problem is that the children 'don't know grammar' and wants the teacher to start articles and verb forms so the Class 5 teacher is satisfied next year.
1. Diagnose what the children can and cannot do, and judge whether the head teacher's grammar-first remedy is supported by this evidence.
Read the worked answer
What they can do: produce memorised formulaic chunks with good pronunciation - the greeting is a routine, not language use. They can also recognise a picture's meaning: Rani's 'Water' shows she has understood the image and has a label, but no sentence frame and no confidence to risk more.
What they cannot yet do: understand an unpredictable spoken question, and respond with even a short phrase. With four periods a week and no exposure at home, they have had almost no comprehensible input, so the bottleneck is listening and meaning, not grammar terminology.
What the test measured: copying and spelling accuracy, not language. Twenty-three below 10 reflects the test's design as much as the learners.
Judgement on the head teacher's remedy: grammar-first is not supported here. Articles and verb forms explained to children who cannot yet follow 'Are you hungry?' add a third unknown on top of unknown words and unknown sounds. Primary L2 sequence is listening, then speaking, then reading and writing; grammar is met first as a pattern in rhymes and routines and named later, in Std 5 and beyond.
But negotiate, don't refuse. The head teacher's real worry is continuity into Class 5. Agree that the same structures will be covered orally as patterns ('He is drinking', 'She is eating') and formally named in Class 5, and show the Class 5 teacher the oral checklist used in Std 4.
2. Plan a 10-minute daily oral routine and show how the four weekly periods will be used with 38 children and no extra materials.
Read the worked answer
The 10-minute daily routine (same every day, content recycled):
- 2 min: action rhyme already known, children joining in.
- 3 min: TPR commands - stand, touch the window, show me red, open the door. No English production demanded, only comprehension.
- 3 min: picture talk. One large picture, three questions: 'Who is this?', 'What is he doing?', 'Is he happy?' Accept one word, then model the full frame: 'He is drinking water.'
- 2 min: pair echo - 'I have a ___' with five objects on the desk.
The four periods:
- Period 1: rhyme plus picture story, teacher telling with actions.
- Period 2: TPR plus pair practice of the same frame.
- Period 3: pre-reading - match words to pictures, letter sounds inside known words (Rani's name, water, bus).
- Period 4: story retell with actions and two written frames copied from the board.
Materials at no cost: the children, the room, names, objects, pictures drawn by children. Label 20 objects around the room and keep a word wall that grows only with words the class can say.
Principle for the first term: at least two-thirds of each period in listening and speaking; writing only words already spoken. Copying five times is replaced by using a word three times in talk and once in writing.
3. How will you assess the speaking of 38 children without a separate examination period, and what will you do with the results?
Read the worked answer
Structure: a four-station carousel inside one normal period - (1) show-me commands, (2) picture question, (3) pair dialogue of three turns, (4) name five things in a picture. Groups rotate; the teacher sits at one station per period, so she observes 8–10 children closely each time and covers the class in four or five periods across two weeks.
Checklist, three criteria, three levels: responds appropriately to what was said; uses the target frame ('He is ___'); is intelligible. Record ✓, developing, or not yet - no marks at first.
Practical safeguards: the tasks are the same ones practised in the daily routine, so nothing is a surprise test; each child's turn is under two minutes; a quiet child may answer a partner first and then the teacher.
Use of results:
- Group children by what they need - a group still on one-word answers works with picture cards, a group ready for frames does pair dialogues.
- Keep two speaking samples per child per term (date, task, note) as a portfolio, and share one sample with parents as evidence of progress.
- Report to the head teacher on how many moved from one word to a frame, which is the honest measure of whether the four periods are working.