I85PREP
⌘ K
NIELIT CCC+ study materials
NIELIT CCC+ study resources

The ₹18,000 Upgrade for Six Ageing Accounting PCs

NIELIT CCC+ · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

The ₹18,000 Upgrade for Six Ageing Accounting PCs

The Nirmal Co-operative Credit Society runs its accounts on six desktop PCs bought in 2016: Core i3-6100, 4 GB DDR4 in a single stick (two of the four DIMM slots are free), a 500 GB 5400 RPM hard disk, Windows 10 Pro 64-bit and a 300 W power supply. Staff use a Tally-style ledger package and LibreOffice. Booting now takes close to four minutes, opening the 40 MB annual ledger file takes about 90 seconds, and during that wait the disk activity light stays on almost continuously while Task Manager shows 2.1 GB of the 3.9 GB usable RAM in use before the file even opens. The vendor quotes ₹2,400 for an 8 GB DDR4 kit, ₹2,600 for a 480 GB SATA SSD supplied, fitted and cloned, and ₹34,000 for a new i5 desktop. The committee has sanctioned ₹18,000 for the whole office and wants a decision before the audit on 30 June, with no data loss and no more than one working day of downtime per machine.

1. Using only the evidence in the setup, which single upgrade should the ₹18,000 buy, and how do you answer the case for adding RAM instead?

Read the worked answer

Decision: six SSDs. The RAM upgrade is the second step, not the first.

Reasoning from symptom to bottleneck:

  • A four-minute boot and a 90-second wait to open a 40 MB file, with the disk light continuously on during the wait, is the classic signature of a storage-bound machine. A 5400 RPM 2.5" drive delivers roughly 50–80 random IOPS; a SATA SSD delivers tens of thousands. Boot and file-open times are dominated by small random reads, which is exactly where the HDD loses.
  • The 2.1 GB figure is before the file opens. It shows memory is tight, but Windows deliberately uses free RAM as cache, and a pagefile on the same slow disk produces the same slow reads. RAM alone would reduce paging but would not turn a four-minute boot into anything acceptable, because most of that time is reading thousands of small files.
  • Budget arithmetic decides the rest: six SSDs = 6 × ₹2,600 = ₹15,600, inside ₹18,000. Six RAM kits = 6 × ₹2,400 = ₹14,400, also inside - but it fixes fewer of the reported symptoms. Buying both = ₹30,000, which the committee has not sanctioned. Six new PCs = ₹2,04,000, roughly eleven times the budget for a workload (ledger entry, word processing) that a 6th-generation i3 still handles once it is not waiting on a disk.
  • Caveat to record in the minutes: confirm each machine really runs 64-bit Windows (the setup says it does). On a 32-bit install, only about 3.2 GB would be usable and any RAM purchase beyond 4 GB would be wasted - that check must happen before the next purchase, not this one.
  • Keep the removed hard disks in caddies as the first-line backup copy of the ledger archive, at no extra cost.

2. After the SSD fitting, two machines still show 85–90% memory use and lag when staff switch between the ledger and LibreOffice. What does that tell you, and what is the correct next action within the same rules (₹18,000 spent, one-day downtime limit)?

Read the worked answer

The SSD removed the disk queue, so the remaining constraint is now visible: genuine memory pressure. With 4 GB and a browser, the ledger package and LibreOffice open together, Windows is paging to disk again - but now the pagefile sits on a fast SSD, so the machine is usable rather than unusable. That is why the symptom changed from "four-minute boot" to "lag when switching".

Next action:

  1. Pilot one machine first. Fit one 8 GB kit (₹2,400), leaving the existing 4 GB stick in a free slot for 12 GB total, and measure Task Manager's Committed figure and the hard-fault rate for a week. Buying six kits on a hunch is what the pilot prevents.
  2. Check compatibility before ordering: free DIMM slots (two are free, so a 2-stick kit can give dual-channel), DDR4 generation and speed (mixing a 2400 MT/s stick with a 2133 MT/s stick is safe but clocks down to the slower speed), and that the ledger package is 32-bit - a 32-bit application cannot use more than about 2 GB however much RAM the PC has, so if that is the culprit RAM will not help and the vendor must be asked about a 64-bit build.
  3. Money: six kits = ₹14,400, which is a fresh sanction, not a reallocation - the ₹18,000 is spent (₹15,600 SSD + ₹2,400 likely contingency). Present the pilot data and ask for ₹14,400 in the next cycle; do not quietly buy two kits and leave four machines inconsistent.
  4. Free wins meanwhile: reduce startup programs, close unused browser tabs, and stop staff keeping three copies of the 40 MB ledger file open at once.

3. Before cloning the existing Windows installation to the new SSDs, list the checks and risks you would put in the vendor's work order.

Read the worked answer
  • Backup first, clone second. A full image of each HDD to an external drive before any cloning; the old disk must not be wiped or reformatted until the SSD has booted and the ledger file opens correctly.
  • Interface and bay: confirm each PC has a free SATA III (6 Gb/s) port and a 2.5" mounting position. A SATA II port halves peak throughput but still beats the HDD by a wide margin, so it is not a blocker - just note it.
  • Power: a 300 W supply is more than adequate; an SSD draws 2–4 W against roughly 6–8 W for the 3.5" HDD, so no PSU change is needed.
  • Clone vs clean install: cloning preserves the ledger software, licence keys and printer settings and fits the one-day downtime rule. A clean install is cleaner but needs the software media, licence proof and reconfiguration - flag it as the fallback if a clone boots with errors.
  • 4K alignment and TRIM: the cloning tool must align partitions for the SSD and Windows must have TRIM enabled (fsutil behavior query DisableDeleteNotify should report 0).
  • Activation: Windows 10 digital licences are tied to the motherboard, so replacing only the disk keeps activation; verify after first boot. If BitLocker is on, suspend it before cloning to avoid a recovery-key prompt.
  • Sequence and verification: boot order in BIOS set to the SSD, then verify boot time, the ledger file open, printer, and the shared folder path before the old disk is retired.
  • Disposal: the old disks hold member financial data, so they stay with the society as backup, not with the vendor.