Four Rooms, One Borewell: A Homestay near Anandpur Sahib
A 26-year-old commerce graduate in a village 8 km from Anandpur Sahib wants to convert three rooms of the family's brick house, plus the courtyard, into a homestay. The house is jointly owned with an uncle who is firmly against 'strangers in the house'. Business is concentrated: Hola Mohalla in March, a handful of wedding-season weekends, and Anandpur Sahib–Nangal weekend traffic; the rest of the year is quiet. The bank has sanctioned ₹6,00,000 at about 10% over five years - an EMI of roughly ₹12,750 - for three attached bathrooms, solar water heating and furniture. Water comes from one borewell that already runs low in May and June, there is no municipal sewer, the nearest hospital is 8 km away, and highway signage is not permitted. The family has no savings left after the loan.
1. Work out whether the venture can service the loan at a realistic occupancy. Show your assumptions and give a clear verdict.
Read the worked answer
Assumptions. Three rooms, average tariff ₹1,600 including breakfast, 365 days.
At 25% occupancy: 3 × 365 × 0.25 ≈ 274 room-nights × ₹1,600 = ₹4,38,400 revenue. Costs: EMI ₹1,53,000; one local helper ₹1,20,000; food, laundry and LPG/electricity ₹90,000; OTA commission and marketing at 10% of revenue ₹43,840; maintenance ₹25,000; insurance, homestay registration and sundries ₹10,000. Total ≈ ₹4,41,840 → a small loss.
At 32% occupancy: revenue ₹5,61,000, the same costs plus a little extra variable cost - surplus of roughly ₹70,000–80,000 a year. That is the whole margin.
Verdict: serviceable, but only above about 30% annual occupancy, and with no cushion - one cancelled Hola Mohalla wipes out the year. Three actions follow. First, phase the spend: build two rooms to a high standard and keep the third for year two, holding back at least ₹1,00,000 of the loan as working capital. Second, keep the first year's two EMIs (₹25,500) in a separate account before the first guest arrives. Third, do not resign from any other income until the 30% threshold is actually met for two quarters.
Reasoning: the danger in seasonal micro-ventures is not the average year, it is the bad March - a fixed EMI against a five-day peak is the single biggest failure mode.
2. Hola Mohalla fills five days and then empties. Design a surge plan that captures that week's revenue without wrecking the borewell or the neighbours' goodwill.
Read the worked answer
Pricing and booking: raise the nightly rate to ₹3,500–4,000 with a two-night minimum, 100% advance, one booking channel only, and a clear no-refund clause inside 14 days. Scarcity, not desperation, sets the price.
Capacity without construction: three rooms at 2 guests each = 6, plus up to 4 courtyard camp beds with shared bathrooms, giving a hard cap of 10–12 guests. The cap is set by water, not by beds.
Water: a guest uses roughly 60–80 litres a day, so 12 guests plus family is around 1,200–1,500 litres daily. Arrange one tanker in advance for the peak days, fit aerators and buckets, and post a simple 'we are a water-scarce village' note in each room. If the borewell yield is unknown, measure it in February, not in March.
People and community: hire two village women for cooking and cleaning on a fixed daily wage agreed beforehand; pre-book a taxi operator; cap noise at 10:00 pm; invite neighbours to the langar-style tea you serve guests, and buy vegetables and milk from them. Goodwill is the surge plan - the same neighbours are the ones who will call an ambulance at 2:00 am.
Money discipline: ring-fence 25% of the week's receipts for maintenance and the low season, and record every booking in a register. Reasoning: Hola Mohalla is not a year's income; it is the year's buffer, and it must be treated as capital, not as a windfall to be spent.
3. What two conditions would you put to the family before a rupee of the loan is spent, and how do you answer the uncle?
Read the worked answer
Condition 1 - a written, preferably registered, family arrangement before construction starts. A plain agreement covering which rooms are used, who pays for what, how revenue is split, who may enter the guest area, and how any partner can exit. Because the house is jointly owned, the loan must not be sunk into an undivided asset: take a lease or licence for the three rooms in the venture's name. Reasoning: family disputes, not lack of tourists, are the most common way such ventures die, and a bank will not price that risk for you.
Condition 2 - clearances and safety in place before the first paying guest. Homestay registration under the current Punjab Tourism scheme (verify the prevailing rules and fees), FSSAI registration if meals are served, GST once turnover crosses the threshold, panchayat no-objection, and a locally approved septic tank and soak-pit plan since there is no sewer. Plus a fire extinguisher, first aid, a displayed tariff, a guest register, and a written tie-up with the hospital 8 km away.
Answering the uncle, in his own frame rather than in business language: "You are not getting strangers in the house; you are getting paying guests I host, in three rooms, with the courtyard still ours. Here is the written agreement - your share, your rooms, your right to say no. And here is what the first month would look like, before we spend anything." Then show him the numbers and let him help set the house rules.
Reasoning: consent from the co-owner is an operational asset - without it, every booking becomes a domestic argument in front of a guest.