Ninety Minutes at the Virasat Mela
A school in Bathinda must fill a 90-minute slot at the district Virasat Mela on 21 February. Five applications are on the table: a 12-member male bhangra troupe (20 minutes) whose boliyan include a verse mocking a caste group; a 10-member women's giddha group (18 minutes) that needs a screened changing space; a jhumar group from a neighbouring village (15 minutes) whose leader wants ₹4,000 travel reimbursement not in the ₹40,000 budget; a Sufi qawwali duo (22 minutes) proposing a Bulleh Shah kalam; and a school dhol group (10 minutes). The organisers insist on 'pure traditional' items and no film songs. A parent has objected to the qawwali on religious grounds, and the giddha group says it will withdraw if it is scheduled last, after dark.
1. Design the 90-minute running order and justify each decision.
Read the worked answer
The requested items total 85 minutes, leaving five for links - workable only if the giddha group's changing space is ready and the jhumar party arrives on time. If either fails, the dhol group can be extended by five minutes as a buffer.
Order: dhol (10) opens and holds a moving crowd; giddha (18) second, while daylight lasts and the screened space is free; jhumar (15) third; qawwali (22) fourth, once the audience is settled and the acoustics suit voices; bhangra (20) closes. That is 85 plus 5 minutes of links.
Conditions to record in writing: giddha is not last and not after dark, as requested; the qawwali is introduced as Punjabi literary heritage, not as an act of worship; the bhangra troupe confirms revised boliyan by 15 February. The ₹4,000 travel claim goes to the Mela committee, not out of the school's programme budget.
2. What do you do about the caste-mocking verse in the bhangra boliyan?
Read the worked answer
Folk genres carry satire, and a school should not pretend otherwise. But the school is the host, not a neutral recording device: a boliyan that names and mocks a caste group lands on students in the audience whose families belong to that group, and on the troupe's own members.
First, raise it privately with the troupe leader, not through students or a public announcement. Explain the audience and ask for two or three alternative boliyan from the same repertoire - the tradition is large and the leader will know them. If the leader refuses, drop the item, record the reason, and let the remaining four items fill the slot; do not edit the verse yourself and do not perform it with a cut.
Afterwards, use the episode in class: what does a folk form license, and who carries the cost of a joke?
3. A parent objects to the qawwali on religious grounds. Draft your reply and your fallback.
Read the worked answer
Reply in writing: the qawwali sets verses by Bulleh Shah, a Punjabi poet whose work appears in the Punjabi curriculum; here it is performed as literature and music, not as worship; attendance at the Mela is not attendance at a religious service; the student may sit out that single item with no penalty and no questions asked.
Fallback if the objection hardens: move the qawwali to a smaller side stage, keep the printed programme note explaining the poetic text, and let the other four items carry the main stage. This respects the parent without surrendering the programme.
What should not happen is silent removal on the day. Quietly deleting a shared Punjabi heritage item teaches students that it must be hidden to be safe, which is a far stronger message than any stage placement.