Rajasthan Police SI study materials
Rajasthan Police SI study resources

Two Thousand Angry People in a Four-Metre Lane

Rajasthan Police SI · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

Two Thousand Angry People in a Four-Metre Lane

It is the sixth day of a ten-day temple fair in a Rajasthan district. The mela is held in a temple town whose main lane is 4 metres wide, lined with about 60 shops; on the peak day the administration expects 1.2 lakh visitors, against 80,000 last year. You are the SI in charge of the mela police post, with 30 constables, 10 Home Guards, two ambulances and one fire tender. At 19:10, during the evening aarti, a WhatsApp forward begins circulating in three local groups: 'a girl has been molested near the prasad shop, police are protecting the accused'. Within minutes a crowd of about 2,000, mostly young men, starts moving towards the prasad shop, and some begin shouting slogans. The main lane is also the only ambulance route. The SDM is 20 minutes away, the nearest reserve company 35 minutes away, and a VIP is scheduled to arrive at 20:00. No one has yet made a written complaint about any molestation.

1. State the first five things you do in the next ten minutes, in priority order, with the reason for each.

Read the worked answer

Priority order: life and crowd safety first, verification second, rumour third, evidence last.

  1. Inform the control room, SDM and SP at once, request the reserve company immediately (35 minutes means it must start now, not later), and ask for the ambulances to be repositioned off the main lane. Information upward is not a formality - the SDM is the officer who can impose prohibitory orders, and the reserve cannot move without the call.
  2. Send a small verification team - including two women police - to the prasad shop. Their job is twofold: if a girl is actually there and in distress, she gets help and a statement at the women's help desk; and the team produces an authoritative answer to the rumour within minutes. A rumour dies from a verified fact, not from a denial.
  3. Do not push 2,000 people frontally down a 4-metre lane. A frontal lathi charge in a lane with 60 shops and one exit is how stampedes start. Instead, put a cordon line across the lane at the last junction before the shop, open and mark a side exit, and hold the ground you have.
  4. Use the public address system and the mela committee. Announce that a women's police team is at the prasad shop and that anyone with information should come to the help desk. Simultaneously ask three or four respected shopkeepers and mela committee members to walk ahead of the crowd and appeal for calm - a local voice moves a local crowd faster than a police voice.
  5. Protect the ambulance route by prepositioning barricades and marking a diversion, and log every instruction and time in the station diary.

Force - tear gas, lathi charge - is a last resort, only after a lawful dispersal order, and only on the orders of a competent officer.

2. Which legal powers are available to you, which are not, and what are the limits on each?

Read the worked answer

Available to the SI:

  • Section 129 CrPC (dispersal of unlawful assembly): you may command an assembly of five or more persons to disperse, and may use force if it does not. Limit: the order must be given clearly and, where practicable, recorded; force must be the minimum necessary and proportionate.
  • Section 151 CrPC (preventive arrest): only where there is a design to commit a cognizable offence and arrest is necessary to prevent it. Limit: it is not a tool for clearing a crowd; every arrest must be justified on its own facts and the person produced and released as the law requires, or the station will face complaints and habeas corpus petitions.
  • Section 107/116 CrPC (security proceedings): for specific persons who are likely to breach the peace - a targeted tool, not a crowd tool.
  • Section 41/41A CrPC: arrest of identifiable persons committing offences such as assault, mischief, or obstructing a public servant.
  • Rumour trail: Section 505 IPC for statements conducing to public mischief, and IT Act provisions where a fake account was used. Limit: the content must actually tend to cause alarm or incite an offence; a clumsy forward by a frightened resident is not the same as a designed rumour.

Not available to the SI:

  • Section 144 CrPC (now Section 163 BNSS) can be imposed only by the Executive Magistrate/SDM - you can and should recommend it, but you cannot issue it.
  • Mass detention of 2,000 people is not a legal option at all.
  • Section 228A IPC bars disclosure of the identity of a victim of certain sexual offences - so no name, photo or locality detail goes to the press or into a WhatsApp reply, even if the allegation is unverified.

3. How do you handle the rumour and the 20:00 VIP arrival, and what do you document?

Read the worked answer

Rumour:

  • Get the verified fact from the help-desk team, then issue one official message - from the district police's verified handle and over the mela PA - stating time, place, what was checked, and where to give information. A named, time-stamped update outperforms ten rounds of 'nothing has happened'.
  • Ask the district cyber cell to trace the original forwarder and the group admins; do not confront admins publicly, as that converts them into leaders of the crowd.
  • Keep the allegation itself alive: an unverified molestation report is still a report. If a complainant appears, register it and investigate - a rumour that gets dismissed without a check is how the next incident goes unpunished.

VIP at 20:00:

  • The VIP route and the ambulance route are the same 4-metre lane. Recommend to the SDM, in writing, either a route change or a 30-minute deferment until the crowd is dispersed, and keep a clear corridor either way. The SI's job is to give the SDM options with reasons; the SDM decides and the decision goes on record.
  • Do not strip the cordon line to line the VIP route - that is exactly when the crowd surges.

Documentation: station diary entries with times; a written deployment order; the log of instructions given and received (including the reserve call at 19:12); crowd estimates with the basis; the injured list, if any; copies of every public message issued; and the recommendation on the VIP route. If an inquiry is ordered afterwards, these papers are the difference between a professional decision and an unexplained one.