Fire Claim with Underinsurance and Late Notice
A hardware store in a small town is insured under a standard fire policy. A short circuit starts a fire at night. Stock worth about ₹6 lakh at cost is destroyed; the building suffers ₹1 lakh of damage. The policy shows a sum insured of ₹15 lakh for stock, but the owner's stock register and purchase invoices indicate that stock worth about ₹25 lakh was actually held at the time. The policy contains an average clause and a ₹5,000 excess. The owner was busy shifting salvage and informed the insurer only on the ninth day. The insurer appoints a surveyor and then writes that late notice and underinsurance may reduce the claim. The building is separately insured for ₹10 lakh and the insurer accepts that the building sum insured is adequate. The owner has submitted a claim of ₹7 lakh and threatens to approach a consumer forum. He asks the branch's insurance desk for help.
1. Calculate the admissible stock claim under the average clause, showing each step. State any assumptions.
Read the worked answer
Average clause: claim = loss × sum insured ÷ actual value at risk. Stock loss is ₹6,00,000; sum insured is ₹15,00,000; actual stock is ₹25,00,000. Stock claim = 6,00,000 × 15/25 = ₹3,60,000.
Building damage is ₹1,00,000 and, on the assumption that the building sum insured is adequate, it is payable in full. Total before excess = ₹4,60,000. If the policy applies a single ₹5,000 excess to the claim, net payable = ₹4,55,000; if the excess applies separately to each section, net = (3,60,000 − 5,000) + (1,00,000 − 5,000) = ₹4,50,000. Salvage recovered from damaged stock must be deducted. The owner's ₹7 lakh claim is not the insured loss after the average clause. Assumption: no other policy, salvage or depreciation adjustment.
2. Does late intimation automatically defeat the claim? Explain how the owner should respond.
Read the worked answer
Late intimation is a breach of a policy condition, but it does not automatically cancel a genuine claim. The insurer must show that the delay materially prejudiced its investigation, for example by making it impossible to verify stock or the cause of fire. The owner should give a written explanation: he was shifting salvage and securing the premises, and he reported as soon as he could.
He should supply the fire-brigade report, electricity-board report, photographs, purchase invoices, stock register, sales records and the surveyor's report. Ask the insurer to state in writing how the delay prejudiced the assessment. Do not start with a consumer forum; first use the insurer's grievance officer and then the insurance ombudsman if needed. Keep the damaged stock and salvage available for inspection.
3. What documents and negotiation points should the insurance desk prepare?
Read the worked answer
Prepare a claim file: policy and schedule, premium receipt, claim form, fire-brigade and police reports, electricity-board findings, photographs, stock register, purchase and sales invoices, bank/UPI records, salvage records, surveyor's report and correspondence.
Negotiation points: apply the average clause transparently; check whether the ₹25 lakh stock value is supported by invoices and not inflated; deduct salvage; confirm the excess treatment; ask for the building loss to be settled separately if it is adequately insured. Request a written loss assessment. If the insurer relies on late notice, ask for evidence of prejudice. Keep the customer informed and avoid advising him to inflate the claim; that would be fraud.