Choosing a Channel for a Charity Bake-Sale Request
You are secretary of the Eco Club at a school that requires formal letters for all requests to the principal's office. The club wants to hold a charity bake sale on 5 September from 11:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. in the school canteen. The principal's office has three conditions: every item must carry an allergy label; two parent volunteers must be present; and no fizzy drinks may be sold. Proceeds will go to flood relief. The letter must be 120–150 words, use a formal salutation and closing, and fit on one page. A classmate suggests sending a WhatsApp message instead, arguing that it is faster and that the principal already knows about the event. Your teacher warns that the office rejects requests that do not follow the letter format, but also that a stiff, legalistic tone may make the event sound risky.
1. Should you send the WhatsApp message or the formal letter? Decide, and justify using the audience, the purpose, and the office's constraints.
Read the worked answer
Send the formal letter and, if speed matters, send a short WhatsApp note only to alert the principal that the letter is coming. The audience is the principal's office, which has an explicit format rule; a WhatsApp message may not be logged, may not reach the decision-maker, and may look as if the club is bypassing procedure. The purpose is not just to inform but to obtain written permission, so the letter creates a record of the date, time, conditions, and volunteers. The 120–150-word limit is compatible with a letter; it is not a reason to choose a less formal channel. The classmate is right that the principal may already know about the event, but prior knowledge does not replace consent. Tone should be courteous and concrete, not legalistic.
2. Draft the opening two sentences and the closing of the letter. Keep the opening within 40 words and the closing within 25 words.
Read the worked answer
Opening: 'I am writing on behalf of the Eco Club to request permission to hold a charity bake sale in the school canteen on 5 September from 11:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. The proceeds will go to flood relief.' (39 words) Closing: 'We would be grateful for your approval and will ensure that all conditions are met. Yours faithfully, [Name], Secretary, Eco Club.' (23 words) The opening names the writer's role, the request, the date, time, place, and purpose in one sentence, so the reader does not have to hunt for the ask. The closing is polite but not grovelling; it repeats compliance with conditions without listing them again.
3. How should the letter handle the allergy-label and fizzy-drink conditions so that it sounds responsible rather than defensive? Write one sentence you would include and explain your choice.
Read the worked answer
Include: 'Every item will carry a clear allergy label, two parent volunteers will supervise, and the stall will sell no fizzy drinks.' This sentence turns the three conditions into a compact compliance statement. It sounds responsible because it is specific and active: 'will carry', 'will supervise', 'will sell no'. It avoids defensive phrasing such as 'We promise not to...' or 'We are aware that...', which draws attention to risk. It also saves words, which matters under the 120–150-word limit. If the principal's office needs more detail, the letter can add one short clause about nut-free options, but the main sentence should stay concrete and calm.