Cultural Accuracy and Budget in a Chittorgarh Festival
A district cultural festival committee in Chittorgarh has ₹2,00,000 for four proposed items. Proposal A: Ghoomar performance by a women's group from Mewar, ₹80,000. Proposal B: Kalbelia dance by a Kalbelia troupe from Jaisalmer, ₹1,00,000. Proposal C: Kachhi Ghodi display from Shekhawati, described in the proposal as 'a women-only martial dance', ₹60,000. Proposal D: a puppet show on Tejaji, ₹40,000. The committee must select items that are culturally accurate, within budget, and representative of different regions. A sponsor insists on including C as written because the poster is already printed. The coordinator asks you to review the proposals before the final approval meeting tomorrow.
1. Evaluate each proposal for cultural accuracy and identify which description needs correction.
Read the worked answer
Proposal A is acceptable: Ghoomar is a traditional Rajasthani folk dance performed by women and is associated with Mewar and other regions. Proposal B is acceptable: Kalbelia is associated with the Kalbelia community of Jaisalmer and is recognised for its distinctive dance and music. Proposal D is acceptable: Tejaji is a folk deity of Rajasthan, and a puppet narrative on Tejaji is a legitimate cultural presentation.
Proposal C needs correction. Kachhi Ghodi is a folk dance of the Shekhawati region performed by men, often using dummy horses and depicting bandit or community narratives; it is not a women-only martial dance. The item can remain if the description and performers match the actual tradition.
2. Recommend a final selection within ₹2,00,000 and explain the trade-offs.
Read the worked answer
A defensible selection is B + C + D = ₹1,00,000 + ₹60,000 + ₹40,000 = ₹2,00,000, provided C is corrected. This covers Jaisalmer (Kalbelia), Shekhawati (Kachhi Ghodi) and the Tejaji folk tradition, giving regional and thematic variety. It uses the full budget but leaves no contingency.
An alternative is A + C + D = ₹1,80,000, which covers Mewar, Shekhawati and the Tejaji tradition and keeps ₹20,000 as a buffer for sound, lighting or contingencies. A + B = ₹1,80,000 is strong on dance but omits Shekhawati and folk narrative. A + B + D costs ₹2,20,000 and is over budget.
The committee should choose based on its stated priority: if regional spread is primary, B + C + D is suitable after correction; if financial caution is primary, A + C + D is safer.
3. How should the committee handle the sponsor's insistence and the printed poster?
Read the worked answer
The committee should not present a factually wrong description merely because a poster is printed. It should inform the sponsor that Kachhi Ghodi is performed by men, not as a women-only martial dance, and that the poster wording must be corrected through an errata slip, a corrected digital version or a public announcement. If the sponsor refuses any correction, the committee should either drop C or include it only with an accurate script, because cultural misrepresentation would damage the festival's credibility.
The sponsor can still be acknowledged without giving control over factual content. The committee should record the decision and the correction in its minutes so that responsibility is clear.