Priya's Tiffin Service: Independent Brand or Franchise?
Priya plans to start a tiffin service from a rented kitchen in Tiruchirappalli. She estimates fixed costs of ₹48,000 per month (rent, salaries, licence, utilities) and variable cost of ₹55 per meal. She plans to charge ₹90 per meal and expects to sell 1,500 meals a month. A franchise brand offers her its name, recipes and app listing for a monthly fixed fee of ₹10,000 plus royalty of 6% of sales. Priya's cousin says the franchise is safer because 'the brand will bring customers'. Priya has also been told that she must obtain an FSSAI licence, display prices, and accept digital payments. She has savings of ₹1,50,000 and can borrow a small amount. She is unsure whether to start independently or take the franchise.
1. Compute the break-even point in meals and the margin of safety for the independent plan.
Read the worked answer
Contribution per meal = selling price − variable cost = ₹90 − ₹55 = ₹35.
Break-even point = Fixed costs ÷ Contribution per meal = ₹48,000 ÷ ₹35 = 1,371.43 meals, rounded up to 1,372 meals per month.
At the expected 1,500 meals:
- Margin of safety in meals = 1,500 − 1,372 = 128 meals
- Margin of safety ratio = 128 ÷ 1,500 × 100 = 8.5%
- Profit = (1,500 × ₹35) − ₹48,000 = ₹52,500 − ₹48,000 = ₹4,500
The margin of safety is very thin. A fall of only about 9% in demand would wipe out profit. Priya should treat the independent plan as viable but fragile, and should keep a cash buffer for the months when demand is below expectation.
2. Evaluate the franchise offer using break-even analysis. Should Priya accept it at the expected demand?
Read the worked answer
Royalty = 6% of ₹90 = ₹5.40 per meal. New contribution = ₹90 − ₹55 − ₹5.40 = ₹29.60. New fixed costs = ₹48,000 + ₹10,000 = ₹58,000.
Franchise break-even = ₹58,000 ÷ ₹29.60 = 1,959.46 meals, rounded up to 1,960 meals per month.
At 1,500 meals, total contribution = 1,500 × ₹29.60 = ₹44,400. After fixed costs of ₹58,000, the result is a loss of ₹13,600. The franchise is therefore not viable at the expected demand. The brand would have to raise demand by about 460 meals a month merely to break even, and by more than that to beat the independent plan. Priya should reject it unless the franchisor can show evidence of much higher demand, reduce the fixed fee or royalty, or offer marketing support that reliably lifts sales above 1,960 meals.
3. Identify two business environment or modern practice requirements Priya must comply with, and explain how each affects her cost or demand.
Read the worked answer
Two important requirements are FSSAI licensing and food safety compliance and digital payment acceptance.
FSSAI registration or licence is a legal requirement. It adds a fixed compliance cost (licence fee, possible kitchen upgrades, labelling and hygiene records), which raises her break-even point. But it also builds customer trust; without it she may lose corporate orders and cannot legally operate at scale.
Accepting UPI and card payments is now expected by customers. It can increase demand and speed up collection, but the payment provider charges a transaction fee, and she must keep proper records for GST and income tax. Digital payments also make her depend on internet connectivity and settlement cycles. Priya should include both the compliance cost and the transaction fee in her cost estimates before choosing between the independent and franchise routes.