Three Days, One Hill Station, Forty-Six People
Your school's vocational tourism teacher asks you to vet the travel agent's draft plan for the Class IX–X excursion. Forty-two students and four teachers are going to Darjeeling in the second week of October. The train reaches New Jalpaiguri at 5:40 a.m. on Day 1 and the return train leaves NJP at 6:20 p.m. on Day 3; school reopens on the fourth morning. The sanctioned budget is ₹4,800 per head for travel, food and lodging. The agent quotes ₹5,350 per head because the plan includes both the Tiger Hill sunrise trip and a toy-train joyride. His draft puts Mall Road shopping on Day 1 evening after the five-hour road journey, Tiger Hill at 4 a.m. on Day 2 followed by the toy train from 10 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., and the Himalayan Mountaineering Institute on Day 3 morning before the drive back. Two students are prone to motion sickness and one teacher is diabetic.
1. Identify the two points in the draft that cannot work as written, and explain what makes each unworkable rather than merely tiring.
Read the worked answer
Point 1 - Day 3 is a missed-train plan. The Darjeeling–NJP road run takes about three to three and a half hours in normal traffic and longer in October, when landslide clearance and festival traffic both bite. For a 6:20 p.m. train the group must be on the platform by roughly 5:15 p.m., so the vehicles have to leave Darjeeling by about 1:30 p.m. That squeezes check-out for 46 people with luggage, an institute visit and lunch into one morning, with zero recovery time. If the road is blocked, 46 students miss a train. The flaw is risk, not comfort.
Point 2 - Day 2 ignores the people, not just the clock. A 4 a.m. Tiger Hill start means a 3:30 a.m. wake-up after a five-hour hill drive the previous evening and a late Mall Road walk. The two motion-sick students will be on winding roads at dawn on empty stomachs, and the diabetic teacher's meal and medicine timings are broken twice in one day. Add a 10 a.m. toy-train block and the group has no rest period before a full travel day.
A plan that only works if nothing goes wrong, and that ignores two known medical conditions, is not a plan a school can sign.
2. The budget gap is real. Show the arithmetic of the gap, and decide which single inclusion you would drop, with reasons.
Read the worked answer
The gap: ₹5,350 − ₹4,800 = ₹550 per head. For 46 people: 550 × 46 = ₹25,300 over budget.
Drop the toy-train joyride, keep Tiger Hill.
- Cost: the joyride is the item with the highest per-head price in almost every Darjeeling quote (roughly ₹1,000–1,500), so it alone can close a ₹550 gap; Tiger Hill is usually a shared jeep at a fraction of that.
- Time: the joyride locks 2.5 hours of a short day that is already carrying a 4 a.m. start.
- Risk: toy-train services are frequently cancelled or curtailed, which means a paid inclusion the agent may have to refund or substitute at the last minute.
- Experience: Tiger Hill is the one sight a Kolkata student will remember; the joyride is a repeatable extra.
If the agent's costing still does not close the gap, ask for group rates on two dinners replaced by packed meals, and cap the shopping halt at 45 minutes. Get the revised per-head figure in writing before the school collects money - a verbal quote cannot be defended to parents.
3. Name the three things the agent's written confirmation must state before the school pays any advance, and say why each matters for this particular group.
Read the worked answer
- Vehicle type and seat count, plus a standby. Forty-six passengers with luggage cannot travel in a 35-seater. The note must name the vehicle (49-seater, or two 27-seaters) and say what happens if one breaks down on the hill road. Without this, the group is split or stranded.
- Meal plan with exact timings, including the diabetic teacher's schedule. State the number of meals, veg/non-veg counts and the serving times that fit the 4 a.m. start; a plan that serves dinner at 10 p.m. after a 3:30 a.m. wake-up is a health incident waiting for a parent's complaint.
- Rooming list with bed configuration and the dropped inclusions. Say clearly what has been removed (joyride) so nobody promises students a train ride, how many rooms are triples/quads, and that boys' and girls' rooms are on separate floors where possible.
Add cancellation and refund terms and a 24-hour emergency number. Insist that the school's copy carries the agency's stamp and the date - the confirmation, not the brochure, is what a consumer forum will read.