Organs and Forms of Government
The three organs
Legislature (makes law, represents, scrutinises, controls finance), executive (formulates and implements policy; political versus permanent/civil-service wings), judiciary (adjudicates, interprets, reviews). Understand the functions of each and the devices of legislative control: question hour, motions, committees, confidence votes.
Parliamentary vs presidential
- Parliamentary: executive drawn from and responsible to the legislature; fusion of powers; collective responsibility; head of state distinct from head of government; flexible tenure; typically weak separation.
- Presidential: separately elected executive; fixed tenure; no legislative confidence requirement; strict separation with checks; head of state and government combined.
- Semi-presidential: dual executive (directly elected president plus cabinet responsible to legislature).
Unitary vs federal
- Unitary: single centre of authority; sub-units created and devolved by the centre; constitution usually flexible.
- Federal: division of powers entrenched in a written constitution, shared sovereignty, a supreme court as arbiter, bicameral representation of units, and units with their own constitutional competence.
- Confederation: units retain primary sovereignty; weak centre.
Traps
'Fusion of powers' applies to parliamentary systems; do not say presidential systems fuse powers. A unitary state can be decentralised without being federal. Holding elections does not make a system federal. Do not equate 'flexible tenure' with instability in a way that denies the parliamentary executive's capacity for strong government.
Rule of thumb
Test federalism by asking: are the units' powers constitutionally entrenched and arbitrated by an independent court? If yes, it is federal; if the centre can unilaterally reshape them, it is unitary.
Worked example: A system where the prime minister must retain a legislative majority, and where ministers are also legislators, is parliamentary: it displays fusion of powers and collective responsibility.