Deteriorating Cloud Base over Rising Terrain
Pilot on a VFR flight in a C172, 25 nm leg over rising terrain. Terrain along track rises to 1,800 ft AMSL. Current cloud base is 2,500 ft AMSL, visibility 8 km, and the forecast is temporary 1,500 ft cloud base and 4 km visibility in rain. The pilot is at 3,500 ft AMSL, 45 min fuel, and the alternate is 20 nm back. The direct GPS route shows lower terrain 5 nm ahead, but the aircraft would need to descend to 2,300 ft to stay below the cloud. The pilot has no instrument rating. There is no icing forecast, but the temperature is +2°C at 3,500 ft. The pilot is tempted to continue because the destination is only 12 nm away and the GPS shows a direct track.
1. Can the pilot legally and safely continue at 2,300 ft AMSL under VFR? Explain the limiting factors.
Read the worked answer
No. At 2,300 ft over terrain rising to 1,800 ft, the aircraft would have only about 500 ft terrain clearance, which is below the normal VFR requirement of 1,000 ft above terrain in this case. The cloud base is 2,500 ft, so at 2,300 ft the pilot would be only 200 ft below cloud, and the forecast temporary 1,500 ft base would put cloud below the aircraft. Visibility 8 km is acceptable now, but the temporary 4 km and rain would reduce it. Continuing at 3,500 ft would put the aircraft in cloud. The pilot cannot maintain both terrain clearance and cloud separation along the route, so VFR cannot be assured. The GPS showing lower terrain does not solve the cloud-base problem.
2. What should the pilot do now, and what should be considered in the diversion?
Read the worked answer
Turn back to the alternate or divert to a route with lower terrain and better weather. Advise ATC if in controlled airspace. Consider fuel: 45 min is enough for the 20 nm back, but the pilot should not spend it probing the weather. Check the alternate's current weather and runway, and plan to land with reserve. Do not climb into cloud or descend below safe terrain clearance. If the weather closes in before reaching the alternate, declare an emergency and use the nearest suitable landing area. The destination being 12 nm away is not a reason to continue; the weather trend and terrain are the deciding factors.
3. If the pilot decides to climb to 4,500 ft to stay above the cloud, what are the risks?
Read the worked answer
Climbing above the cloud does not make the flight VFR unless the pilot can maintain cloud separation and see the surface; at 4,500 ft the aircraft would be above the cloud base and likely in cloud during the climb. Without an instrument rating, entering cloud is a serious risk. The pilot could lose visual reference, suffer spatial disorientation, and lose terrain separation on descent. The temperature at 4,500 ft may be near freezing, so icing is possible even if not forecast. A VFR pilot should not use a climb through cloud as a workaround. The safer option is to divert or turn back while visual conditions remain.