Deadline pressure after 9.5 hours of driving
A refrigerated truck driver started at 05:00 in Baghdad for a 520 km run to Basra. At 19:30 he has driven 9 h 35 min and been on duty 13 h 10 min, including two 20-minute stops. He slept 3.5 hours the previous night in the cab because the yard generator ran until 02:00. His company policy limits driving to 9 hours and duty to 12 hours in any 24-hour period, with at least 8 continuous hours of rest before the next shift. He is 85 km from the delivery point; the customer appointment is 21:00 and the dispatcher says that unless he arrives, the company will lose the contract. The driver says he feels fine but has yawned repeatedly, drifted across the lane line twice, and is squinting in the setting sun. The cab is 24°C but he has drunk only one bottle of water since noon.
1. Should the driver continue the last 85 km? Apply the hours limits and the evidence of fatigue.
Read the worked answer
No. He has already exceeded both limits: 9 h 35 min driving against a 9-hour maximum, and 13 h 10 min duty against a 12-hour maximum. The remaining 85 km would add roughly 1 to 1.5 hours, making the breach worse. The policy also requires 8 continuous hours of rest before the next shift, which cannot be met if he continues and then starts again. The contract penalty is a commercial matter, not a legal justification. The fatigue evidence is objective: only 3.5 hours' sleep, repeated yawning, two lane drifts and squinting in low sun. 'Feeling fine' is unreliable because impaired drivers routinely underestimate their own fatigue. He must stop at a safe, secure location and not treat the appointment as more important than the driving limit.
2. Explain the specific fatigue and fitness risks in this situation, including the effects of sleep debt and dehydration.
Read the worked answer
A 3.5-hour sleep opportunity creates a sleep debt that cannot be reversed by willpower. The time of day matters: 19:30 to 21:00 is a period when circadian alertness can dip, and the low sun adds glare and eye strain. Dehydration from drinking only one bottle of water since noon worsens headache, concentration and reaction time; cab heat and air-conditioning can also dehydrate. The lane drifts suggest microsleeps or attention lapses, which can become a fall-asleep crash within seconds. Fatigue impairs judgement, so the driver may not recognise risk, and it slows braking and steering responses. Monotonous motorway driving and deadline pressure increase risk-taking. Continuing would combine a legal breach with a high probability of a serious crash, and the driver would also be personally responsible for driving while unfit.
3. Set out a safe plan for the next 12 hours, including communication and record-keeping.
Read the worked answer
Stop at the nearest safe, lit and secure parking area or depot; do not stop on the hard shoulder unless there is no alternative. Notify the dispatcher immediately that the driving and duty limits are exceeded and that the delivery must be rescheduled or handed to a relief driver who has had the required rest. Inform the customer of the revised ETA. Record the driving and duty times, the reason for stopping, the location, and the rest start time. The driver should drink water, eat a light meal, secure the cab and take at least 8 continuous hours of rest before any further driving. He should not use energy drinks or caffeine to push on. If a relief driver is sent, ensure that driver is fit and within limits, and complete a proper handover of the refrigerated load and vehicle.