Cloze with Word-Form Options: Four Blanks, One Correct Choice
Arman is on a four-blank cloze. The passage and the options are printed together:
'City planners have long argued that a city's (1)______ performance rarely matches its reputation. A (2)______ small park can lift surrounding rents more than a stadium costing ten times as much, (3)______ the two are rarely compared in the same budget line. Researchers have (4)______ on fine-grained rent data, and their findings have begun to change how councils justify spending.'
(1) A. economical B. economic C. economy D. economically (2) A. surprise B. surprised C. surprising D. surprisingly (3) A. therefore B. even though C. moreover D. unless (4) A. relied B. relied in C. rely D. depending
Arman's answers are (1) A, (2) C, (3) A, (4) A. He explains his method: 'I read the sentence and picked the option that sounded most natural, then moved on. I only had forty seconds per blank.' He got one right.
1. Explain the word-form decision in blanks (1) and (2), including the quick test that separates the options.
Read the worked answer
Blank (1): B, economic. The word modifies performance in the phrase 'a city's ___ performance'. Economic is the relational adjective meaning 'of the economy' - economic performance, economic policy. Economical means 'thrifty, money-saving' and describes devices, methods or people (an economical car). Economy is a noun; a noun placed before another noun forms a compound (an economy car) and cannot carry the relational sense here. Economically is an adverb and cannot modify a noun.
Quick test: substitute financial. If it fits, economic is the answer. If the sense is 'cheap to run', economical is the answer.
Blank (2): D, surprisingly. The word being modified is the adjective small, not the noun park: the phrase is [surprisingly] [small] [park]. Adverbs modify adjectives; adjectives modify nouns. If surprising were chosen it would attach to park, producing the impossible reading 'a park that is surprised'. Surprise is a noun/verb and surprised describes a person experiencing surprise.
Both blanks are solved by the same move Arman never made: identify the head word being modified first, then choose the form the grammar requires.
2. Decide blank (3) by logic and by clause structure, and say why 'therefore' is the trap.
Read the worked answer
The two halves are: a small park can lift rents more than a stadium costing ten times as much; and the two are rarely compared in the same budget line. The second half does not follow from the first - it stands in spite of it. That is concession/contrast, so even though (B) is correct.
therefore would assert that the neglect is a consequence of the cost-effectiveness, which is logically backwards: if small parks were known to be more effective per unit of cost, you would expect them to be compared more, not less. moreover would add a compatible point rather than oppose one. unless would require a condition and a hypothetical.
Structure confirms the choice: even though is a subordinator and must introduce a full clause with its own subject and verb - the two are rarely compared in the same budget line supplies exactly that. Therefore and moreover are conjunctive adverbs and typically need a following comma or a new sentence, so punctuation is a second, independent signal.
Trap analysis: therefore is the highest-frequency connector in academic prose, and candidates pick it whenever the second clause 'sounds like a conclusion'. The reliable check is to ask whether the second clause would still be true if the first were reversed.
3. Blank (4): justify A and explain what B, C and D each test.
Read the worked answer
The auxiliary have requires a past participle, so the form must be relied. The following preposition settles it too: the verb is rely on, and on is printed after the blank.
- B. relied in - correct participle, wrong dependent preposition. This is the true danger: a candidate who checks form but not collocation will mark it and move on.
- C. rely - a bare form, impossible after have in the active perfect; it would only work as have to rely or have been relying.
- D. depending - a present participle, which would need an auxiliary (have been depending on) and changes the aspect of the sentence.
So the blank tests two things simultaneously, and only one option satisfies both. Method: fill the gap provisionally with whatever gives the right grammatical form, then re-read the whole clause with the printed preposition attached before committing. Forty seconds is not the problem here - the problem is checking one variable instead of two.