Retail Co-Tenancy Trigger, Rent Relief, and CAM Dispute
A 92,000 SF neighborhood retail center has 14 tenants. The 32,000 SF anchor closed eight weeks ago and is paying no rent. Eight small-shop leases contain a co-tenancy clause: if the anchor is not open, affected tenants may pay 75% of base rent until a replacement opens. A 1,200 SF coffee shop paying $32/SF has given notice and requests 50% rent relief, citing lost foot traffic. Three inline spaces are vacant. The 2024 CAM reconciliation shows actual CAM of $9.50/SF versus $8.75/SF estimated; the tenant is disputing the $900 true-up. The owner wants to hold the line and send default notices. The center has $180,000 in reserves and a $1.1 million loan covenant requiring 1.20x DSCR; current DSCR is 1.24x.
1. Does the coffee shop get 50% relief? Calculate the contractual remedy and recommend a response.
Read the worked answer
Verify before conceding
Read the clause for trigger, notice, cure period, and whether relief is automatic. If triggered, the contractual remedy is 75%, not 50%: $38,400 × 75% = $28,800, a $9,600 annual reduction. A 50% request would be $19,200, which exceeds the lease.
Send a written response confirming the calculation and requesting proof of notice. Do not send a default notice if the tenant is complying; that weakens the center's position and invites counterclaims. Offer a temporary 25% abatement for six months ($4,800) only in exchange for a two-year extension or a replacement-anchor cooperation clause. Tie relief to leasing milestones. At 1.24x DSCR, losing the tenant and increasing vacancy is worse than a controlled concession.
2. How should you handle the CAM true-up while the co-tenancy dispute is ongoing?
Read the worked answer
Separate CAM from co-tenancy rent. Reconcile $9.50 versus $8.75: an 8.6% increase; the tenant's 1,200 SF share is $0.75 × 1,200 = $900. Provide the ledger, invoices for snow removal and insurance, and a 30-day payment plan. Waive the late fee if paid on time, but do not waive principal without owner approval. Explain that CAM is not reduced by the co-tenancy clause unless the lease says so. Document all communications.
3. What should you advise the owner about sending default notices to all affected tenants?
Read the worked answer
Advise that blanket default notices may trigger co-tenancy claims and accelerate vacancies. The center is already at 1.24x DSCR with little cushion. Recommend a retention strategy: verify each clause, apply the correct 75% remedy, negotiate extensions tied to relief, and fund a leasing plan for the anchor. The $180,000 reserve is insufficient for TI; seek owner capital or lender approval before promising replacement-anchor work.