The Vendor's Cash Offer at the VIP Gate
Kemar is a PSRA-registered guard assigned to the VIP gate at an outdoor music festival in Ocho Rios. His post controls access to a fenced area with a capacity of 300 people. At 9:15 p.m., a food vendor offers him J$15,000 in cash to allow 12 people without VIP wristbands through the gate. The vendor says the group are 'friends of the promoter' and that another guard, Trevor, has already accepted J$8,000 to let 10 people in through the side gate. Kemar's supervisor is on the other side of the venue and cannot be reached by radio. The crowd outside is growing, and people are pushing. Kemar knows the event's security plan requires all VIP entries to be scanned and logged. He earns J$11,000 for the shift. The vendor says, 'Nobody will know. Trevor will back you up.'
1. What ethical and professional issues does the vendor's offer raise for Kemar?
Read the worked answer
The offer is a bribe. Accepting it would mean Kemar is using his position to sell access he is not authorized to sell, and would break the event's access-control plan. The fact that the vendor calls the group 'friends of the promoter' does not cure the problem, because the security plan requires every VIP entry to be scanned and logged. Unlogged entries destroy the accuracy of the capacity count.
The offer also raises a safety issue. The VIP area has a capacity of 300, the crowd outside is pushing, and adding 12 people without control increases the risk of overcrowding or a crush. Kemar's duty is to the safety of everyone at the event, not only to the people at the gate.
Finally, the vendor says Trevor has already accepted money. If true, that is collusion and corruption involving another guard. Kemar's professional and ethical obligation is to refuse the offer and report the attempted bribe, not to treat Trevor's conduct as permission. The amount offered, J$15,000, is more than his shift pay, which makes the temptation real but does not change the analysis.
2. What should Kemar do in the moment and after the event?
Read the worked answer
In the moment, Kemar should refuse the cash clearly and keep his hands visible: 'I cannot accept that. Entry must be scanned and logged.' He should not enter into a negotiation, take the money 'for safekeeping,' or allow the 12 people through. He should keep the gate closed and continue scanning authorized entrants, while watching the crowd for safety.
He should try to contact the supervisor or control room by another means, such as a mobile phone or nearby radio relay. If the crowd is becoming dangerous, he should follow the event's crowd-safety procedure and call for backup rather than leave the gate unmanaged. He should note the vendor's description, the time, the amount offered, and the names or descriptions of the 12 people.
After the event, he should report the bribe attempt in writing to his supervisor and employer, and report the allegation about Trevor. He should preserve any messages or witness details. If the employer does not act, he should consider reporting the matter to the PSRA. He should not confront Trevor alone, because that could create a safety or evidence problem.
3. How should Kemar respond if Trevor later asks him to keep quiet?
Read the worked answer
Kemar should refuse to keep quiet and should not agree to a 'cover story.' He can tell Trevor plainly that he has already refused the vendor's offer and that he will report what he saw and heard. He should avoid a heated argument, especially in a crowded venue, and should not accept any money or favour from Trevor.
He should document Trevor's request as soon as possible, including the time, place, words used, and any witnesses. He should report it through the same channel as the original bribe attempt: supervisor, employer management, and if necessary the PSRA. If Trevor threatens him, Kemar should report the threat and take reasonable steps for his own safety.
The ethical principle is that loyalty to a colleague does not override the duty to report corruption. Silence would make Kemar part of the concealment and could expose the event to overcrowding, financial loss, and reputational damage. Reporting is also the best protection for Kemar himself, because it creates a record that he refused the offer.