A 9°C Chicken Delivery, a Blocked Hand Basin and an Unwashed Probe
At 11:20 on a Tuesday the delivery van arrives with 40 kg of fresh chicken breast, 12 kg of bagged ready-to-eat salad leaves and 20 L of mayonnaise. The chicken probes 9°C at the centre of the top layer, the salad is at 6°C, and the mayonnaise is at 18°C although the label reads "store below 25°C; refrigerate after opening". The walk-in cooler log shows 7°C at 07:00 and no reading since; the thermometer inside the cooler reads 6.5°C. In the prep area a commis is cutting raw chicken on the green board and is reaching for the same board to chop lettuce; the hand-wash basin is holding a jug of stock and a stack of lids; the probe thermometer is on the shelf, unwashed, with dried residue on the stem. Lunch service is at 12:30 with 90 covers booked.
1. Decide what to accept and what to reject from the delivery, item by item, with the reasoning for each decision.
Read the worked answer
Chicken at 9°C - reject. Fresh poultry should arrive at ≤4°C. The top layer is the warmest part of a consignment, so 9°C there means the whole load has been out of temperature control for an unknown period. Chilling it back down does not undo time already spent in the danger zone, and you cannot establish how long that was. Reject it, record the reading and time on the delivery note, photograph it, and inform purchasing and the supplier in writing. Use the record as supplier-performance evidence.
Salad leaves at 6°C - marginal, conditional acceptance. Bagged ready-to-eat leaves should be ≤5°C. At 6°C it is one degree out, so check the use-by date, the condition of the bags, and whether the van has a temperature recorder. If the date is short or the bags are sweating or limp, reject. If accepted, use first (FIFO) and treat it as ready-to-eat - it must never touch a board used for raw meat.
Mayonnaise at 18°C - accept. Do not apply the chilled rule blindly: read the label. Commercial mayonnaise is shelf-stable until opened, and 18°C is inside "store below 25°C". The rule that matters is "refrigerate after opening", which applies to the opened jar in the kitchen, not to the sealed delivery.
General principle: receiving is a control point with pass/fail limits, not a negotiation. The one item that clearly fails is the chicken, and it is also the highest-risk item.
2. Rank the corrective actions you must take before 12:30. For each, say what you would do with the food already involved.
Read the worked answer
Ranked by risk × immediacy:
- Stop the board cross-contamination now. The commis stops. If the green board has already been used for raw chicken, it does not touch lettuce. If any lettuce has already been chopped on that board, discard it - you cannot wash pathogenic contamination off ready-to-eat leaves, and 90 covers is not a reason to try. Wash and disinfect the board, and restock the correct colour-coded board for salad.
- Clear the hand-wash basin. A basin holding a jug of stock and lids is a basin nobody uses. Move them, restock soap and paper towels, and have everyone who handled raw chicken wash hands for 20 seconds. Hand hygiene is the cheapest control in the kitchen and the easiest to lose.
- Wash and sanitise the probe thermometer, and use wipes between readings. An unwashed probe with dried residue is a direct route from raw chicken into cooked food - it is a cross-contamination device if you let it be.
- Take a cooler reading now and record it. At 6.5–7°C the unit is above the ≤5°C target. Assess what has been in there: high-risk items (cooked meats, dairy, cut fruit) that have been above 5°C for more than about four hours should be discarded; raw vegetables are more forgiving. Then get maintenance and move stock to a working unit.
Do first, record as you go - but do not do the paperwork before the physical controls.
3. Which records must exist by the end of this shift, and who needs to be told? Explain what makes a corrective-action record usable rather than decorative.
Read the worked answer
Records required:
- Delivery: the probe reading, the time, the item, the quantity, the decision (rejected/accepted conditionally) and the signature - on the delivery note and in the receiving log. The delivery note is the financial and legal record; the driver signs the rejection.
- Cooler: the actual reading, written in at the time it was taken, plus a note that the 07:00–11:20 gap exists. Do not back-date or fill the blank. A gap that is documented is a management problem; a gap that has been filled in is fraud, and it destroys the credibility of every other record you hold.
- Cross-contamination incident: what was discarded, how much, why, and who authorised it.
- Supplier performance record: the chicken rejection goes here, not just in the bin.
What makes a record usable: a specific number, a time, a quantity, an action and a name. "Rejected - bad temperature" is decorative. "40 kg chicken breast, 9°C at 11:20, rejected, supplier notified, purchasing informed - signed" is usable in an audit, in a complaint, and in a supplier dispute.
Tell: the head chef or manager immediately, because you need authority to discard product; purchasing, in writing; the supplier; and the rest of the brigade at the pre-service briefing, since the board and basin problems are everyone's.