Group Disability, Own-Occupation, and the 'Free' Benefit
Priya is a 38-year-old dentist earning $240,000 a year, married with two children aged 4 and 7. Her employer pays for a group long-term disability plan covering 60% of base salary of $150,000 after a 90-day waiting period, capped at $7,500 a month; the premium is employer-paid and the benefit is taxable. The definition is 'any occupation' after 24 months. She has $500,000 of 20-year term life insurance, a $680,000 mortgage, $95,000 in student loans and $60,000 in savings. She has been quoted an individual own-occupation disability policy with a $9,000 monthly benefit, 90-day wait, to age 65, costing $4,800 a year. She also holds a $50,000 critical illness policy. Her husband earns $70,000 and they spend about $11,000 a month. Priya wants to cancel the individual quote because 'the group plan is free' and instead increase her life insurance.
1. Analyse the disability coverage gap and evaluate Priya's view that the group plan is free.
Read the worked answer
The group plan is not free and not sufficient
- The premium is employer-paid, but the benefit is taxable. At an assumed 30% marginal rate, $7,500 a month becomes roughly $5,250 after tax.
- The cap binds: 60% of $150,000 is $90,000 a year, or $7,500 a month, so the plan pays the maximum. The household spends about $11,000 a month, leaving a pre-tax shortfall of about $3,500 and an after-tax shortfall of about $5,750 before considering the husband's $70,000 income.
- The definition changes to 'any occupation' after 24 months. For a dentist, that is the critical clause: it may require payment only if she cannot perform any occupation for which she is reasonably suited, not merely dentistry. A hand injury or back condition could end clinical work while not satisfying an any-occupation test.
- The group benefit is employment-linked. If she leaves or the employer changes the plan, the coverage ends; individual cover is portable and can be priced at her current age.
The individual quote An own-occupation benefit of $9,000 a month to age 65 for $4,800 a year is about 2% of gross income. If underwriting is available at standard terms, it fills the definitional and portability gaps. The 90-day wait matches the group plan, so the two can coordinate rather than duplicate.
Critical illness The $50,000 lump sum is useful for a covered event but is not income replacement. It should not be counted as disability cover.
2. Recommend priorities between disability cover, life cover and debt reduction, and explain the reasoning to Priya.
Read the worked answer
Priority: disability before additional life insurance Priya's human capital is the household's largest asset. She earns $240,000; her husband earns $70,000. The probability of a long disability during her working years is material, and the consequences are ongoing costs - care, home adaptation, lost income - that a death benefit does not address. Life insurance pays once; disability insurance pays while the need continues.
Life cover check The existing $500,000 term policy should be tested against needs: mortgage $680,000, student loans $95,000, children's education, and income replacement. It may be inadequate, but the marginal dollar is better spent first on the disability gap. Term life is relatively cheap; she can add a layered term policy later, or now at a modest amount if underwriting is easiest while young and healthy.
Debt The $95,000 student loan and $680,000 mortgage are large relative to $60,000 of savings. Debt reduction improves resilience, but aggressively repaying the mortgage before securing income protection is backwards: if income stops, the mortgage still falls due.
Recommended sequence
- Apply for the individual own-occupation policy now, while insurable; consider a future-increase option.
- Keep the group plan as a supplement, not a substitute.
- Review life cover against the mortgage and education needs, and add term cover if the gap is material.
- Then direct surplus cash to debt and to an emergency reserve.
Communication point The comparison is not 'free versus $4,800'. It is the after-tax, any-occupation, non-portable benefit versus a defined own-occupation benefit that follows her if she changes jobs.
3. What underwriting, policy-design and coordination issues should Priya review before signing the individual policy?
Read the worked answer
- Occupation class and duties: confirm the insurer classifies her as a dentist and that the own-occupation definition refers to her specific occupation, not a broader category. Check whether the definition applies for the full benefit period or only for a limited initial period.
- Total disability and residual benefits: does the policy pay partial or residual benefits after a return to reduced hours or income? A dentist with a hand injury may work part-time; a policy that pays only for total disability leaves a gap.
- Benefit offset wording: group and individual benefits may offset each other. The individual policy may reduce its payment by group benefits received. Model the combined after-tax outcome, not the headline $9,000.
- Waiting period coordination: matching the 90-day wait avoids paying for duplicate coverage, but confirm how the group plan defines the waiting period and whether the individual policy requires a separate elimination period.
- Riders: future increase option, cost-of-living adjustment, and waiver of premium. These matter more for a 38-year-old than a small increase in the base benefit.
- Underwriting: complete medical and occupational questionnaires honestly; non-disclosure can void a claim. Confirm exclusions and any occupational exclusions.
- Affordability and review: $4,800 a year is sustainable at her income, but build a review trigger for income changes and policy renewals.
- Tax treatment: confirm whether premiums are personally paid and whether benefits would be tax-free; do not assume.