Beach Cleanup Notice and a Dentist Appointment
Read this notice from your school's English club. 'Beach Cleanup - Saturday, June 8. Meet at the Sunset Beach parking lot at 8:45 a.m. for a safety talk. Cleanup runs from 9:00 to 11:30. Gloves and bags are provided. Bring a hat, a water bottle, and sunscreen. Wear shoes that can get wet. Sign up at the school office by Wednesday, June 5. If it rains, the event is canceled; check the school website at 7:00 a.m. on June 8. Do not park in the beach lot; use the school bus that leaves at 8:20.' You want to join. You have a dentist appointment in Naha on June 8 from 8:30 to 9:15. Your home is a 25-minute bike ride from Sunset Beach and a 10-minute walk from school. The school bus leaves at 8:20.
1. Can you follow the notice exactly as written? Explain using the times and travel details.
Read the worked answer
No. The notice requires you to be at the parking lot at 8:45 a.m. for a safety talk. Your dentist appointment ends at 9:15 in Naha, so even if you travel directly, you cannot arrive by 8:45. The school bus also leaves at 8:20, which is before your appointment ends. Your home is a 25-minute bike ride from the beach, but the problem is the appointment time, not the distance. The notice does not say that late arrival after the safety talk is allowed. Therefore, following the notice exactly is impossible on this schedule.
2. What is the best next step if you still want to take part? Include the sign-up deadline in your reasoning.
Read the worked answer
The best step is to ask the English club before assuming you can join late. You should explain the exact conflict: the dentist appointment is from 8:30 to 9:15, and the safety talk is at 8:45. Ask whether you may join after the safety talk, or whether there is another safety talk. Do this before Wednesday, June 5, because that is the sign-up deadline. If the club says late arrival is not allowed, you should not sign up, because the notice makes the 8:45 safety talk a requirement. Do not plan to park at the beach lot; the notice says to use the school bus, which leaves at 8:20 and also conflicts with the appointment.
3. A classmate says, 'I'll just ride my bike and arrive at 9:00. The cleanup starts at 9:00, so it's fine.' What is wrong with that reasoning?
Read the worked answer
The classmate is confusing the cleanup start time with the meeting time. The notice says to meet at 8:45 for a safety talk; the cleanup itself starts at 9:00. Arriving at 9:00 means missing the safety talk. The notice also says to use the school bus and not park in the beach lot, so a bike plan may conflict with the stated transportation rule. The correct judgement is that the earlier time, 8:45, is the required arrival time, and the 9:00 time is only when the cleaning begins.