Drama Tourism and Overnight Stays in a Coastal Town
A town on the Sea of Japan coast in Shimane Prefecture has a population that fell from 5,200 in 2010 to 4,100 in 2020. The share aged 65 and over rose from 31% to 43%. The main industries are fishing-95 licensed fishermen in 2010 and 62 in 2020-and tourism. The town attracted 48,000 visitors in 2019, but 82% were day-trippers; only 8,500 stayed overnight. After a television drama featured the town's stone lighthouse and seafood, visitors rose to 61,000 in 2023, but overnight stays rose only to 9,100. The town has one bus route, a clinic with two doctors, and a vacant elementary school. The fishery cooperative reports that catch value is stable, but the average age of fishermen is 68 and there are no successors for 40% of boats. The town assembly wants a plan that uses the drama's popularity without damaging the landscape. A developer proposes a 120-room resort hotel on reclaimed coastal land.
1. Calculate the overnight share in 2019 and 2023. What does the change show about the drama's effect, and what indicators should the town use instead of visitor numbers alone?
Read the worked answer
The overnight share was 8,500 ÷ 48,000 ≈ 17.7% in 2019 and 9,100 ÷ 61,000 ≈ 14.9% in 2023. Day visitors rose by 13,000, but overnight guests rose by only 600. So the drama increased footfall but not length of stay; the town remains a pass-through destination. This matters because day-trippers spend less on lodging and meals. The population and aging data show that fishing cannot replace lost workers: licensed fishermen fell 35% while catch value stayed stable, meaning consolidation and fewer households. The plan should target overnight stays, not just visitor counts. Useful indicators include overnight guest nights, average length of stay, spending per visitor, off-season occupancy, and resident satisfaction. A hotel alone may not solve the problem if attractions are dispersed and the bus route is limited; the town could package lighthouse tours, fishing experiences, and local food, and improve transport from the station.
2. Propose a strategy that uses the drama's popularity while protecting the landscape. Explain how success should be measured and one risk of your strategy.
Read the worked answer
Use the drama's image but limit physical development. For example, create a timed shuttle from the station, a small visitor center in the vacant school, and guided walks that cap group size. Home-stay or farm-stay rooms could add beds without a large hotel. Success should be measured by overnight guest nights, local spending, and resident satisfaction-not just visitor numbers. A risk is 'overtourism' damaging the landscape that attracts visitors; a cap and zoning can manage it. The town should also train local guides and support fishermen's direct sales so that income stays local. Because the bus route is limited, transport is a binding constraint. A festival in the off-season could reduce seasonality. The plan should include a review after two years, with data on waste, traffic, and resident complaints.
3. Evaluate the proposed 120-room resort hotel on reclaimed coastal land. Give one benefit, one risk, and one condition you would attach.
Read the worked answer
Benefits: 120 rooms could create construction and service jobs, tax revenue, and more overnight guests; a hotel can market packages and lengthen stays. Risks: reclaimed coastal land may damage scenery and habitats; the town's sewage and water capacity may be strained; the hotel may import labor and supplies, reducing the local multiplier; and it may be seasonal. The developer's proposal should be judged against alternatives such as renovating vacant houses into small inns. Conditions could include a landscape impact assessment, a sewage plan, local hiring targets, and a bond or guarantee. Because the assembly wants to protect the landscape, the hotel should not be approved without evidence that the added rooms are needed; the overnight share is falling, and absolute overnight guests are only 9,100, so 120 rooms may exceed demand. A phased project or a smaller inn would be safer.