The gated report that attracts the wrong readers
Freightwise, a supply chain visibility platform, has published an 18-page, 2,400-word report based on a survey of 600 shippers. The demand team promotes it with a single-image ad that links to a landing page with a full form: name, email, company, phone, role, company size, and annual freight spend. In 60 days: 1.1 million impressions, 0.36% CTR, 4,180 landing page visits, 284 form starts, 196 downloads, and a $152 cost per download against a $90 target. Mobile is 58% of impressions but 31% of downloads. The most valuable content-benchmark tables by mode and region-sits on pages 9-14. Sales says downloads are mostly students and consultants, not shippers. The team has four weeks and enough budget to test one new ad format and one new gate. The CMO wants a recommendation that improves both cost per download and lead quality.
1. Choose the format and gate for the four-week test. Justify with the funnel numbers.
Read the worked answer
Test a Document Ad with a native Lead Gen Form, gated after a 6–8 page teaser. The current funnel: 4,180 visits from 1.1M impressions (0.38%), 284 form starts (6.8%), 196 completions (69%), $152 CPL. The drop-off is not the ad alone; the seven-field form-including phone and annual freight spend-is heavy, and mobile converts at roughly half its impression share. A Document Ad keeps the reader in the feed, showcases the benchmark tables on pages 9–14, and can gate the full report after the teaser. Ask three questions: company, role, and 'Do you manage freight operations?' Remove phone and freight spend; sales can qualify later. Keep the single-image ad as a retargeting unit for people who opened the document but did not finish.
2. Write the ad messaging and creative concept. Explain the choices.
Read the worked answer
Lead with the benchmark gap, not 'download our report': 'Shippers with real-time visibility cut detention costs 18%. See the 2025 benchmark for your mode and region.' The document cover should show a real chart from pages 9–14, with a short caption naming the sample (600 shippers) and the metric. Use a shipper-specific qualifier in the first line-'for shippers managing freight operations'-to deter students and consultants. The CTA should be 'See the benchmark', not 'Download'. In the document, put the strongest benchmark on page 1 and the form on page 6, so the reader gets value before the gate. This improves both conversion and lead quality because the content itself qualifies the reader.
3. Define success metrics and the decision rule after four weeks.
Read the worked answer
Primary metric: cost per qualified download, where qualified = shipper role, company-size fit, and 'yes' to managing freight operations. Target ≤$110; current unqualified CPL is $152. Secondary: CTR (≥0.45%), document completion to page 6 (≥40%), form completion (≥70% of starts), and SQL rate (≥8%). Decision rule after four weeks: roll out if qualified CPL ≤$110 and SQL rate ≥8%; iterate creative or gate if qualified CPL is $110–150; revert if above $150 or SQL rate stays below 5%. Also compare mobile versus desktop completion; if mobile remains below 40% of completions, shorten the document teaser or make the form two steps.