Black Ice, a Snowplow and a Semi on the Bumper
It is minus 22 degrees Celsius with light snow and a 40 km/h north wind. You left Winnipeg at 4 p.m. and are about 40 km from the U.S. border on a two-lane section of Highway 75, southbound, with the cruise control set at 100 km/h. In the wheel tracks the pavement looks dark and glassy while the centre and edges are white with dry snow, and ten minutes ago your tires slipped briefly on a bridge deck. Ahead, a provincial snowplow with amber beacons is clearing the shoulder and spreading salt at roughly 45 km/h, throwing a plume of spray across the lane. A semi has been sitting about 30 m off your rear bumper for the last 10 km. You have been driving for three hours, your eyes feel gritty, and you have yawned four times in the last minute. Your passenger says, "Pass the plow or we'll miss the game."
1. Identify the hazards in this scene and rank them.
Read the worked answer
The dark, glassy look in the wheel tracks while the surrounding snow stays dry and white is the classic signature of black ice, and the slip on the bridge deck is direct evidence that the surface is already compromised; that is the top hazard, because it removes your ability to brake or steer and it is invisible until you are on it. Second is fatigue: three hours of driving, gritty eyes and repeated yawning mean your attention is degrading, and at 100 km/h a two-second lapse covers about 55 m. Third is the semi at 30 m, which cannot stop if you brake for ice ahead. Fourth is the plow, which is throwing a spray plume that hides whatever is beyond it and has a limited field of view itself. Last is the pressure from your passenger, which is not a physical hazard but pushes you toward the worst decision available.
2. Should you pass the snowplow? Explain your reasoning.
Read the worked answer
No, not now. Passing would mean accelerating from 100 km/h to well above 45 km/h into a spray plume that is blinding you at exactly the moment you need to see the surface ahead, on pavement you already suspect is icy, with a semi 30 m behind that will follow you into the manoeuvre. The plow is also spreading salt and may be clearing drifts, so whatever is in front of it is the least predictable road on the highway. The correct approach is to drop back well behind the spray, take the cruise control off so you are controlling speed with your foot, and wait until the plow turns off or the spray clears and you have a long, unobstructed view. When you do pass, do it decisively with plenty of room, never on the shoulder or the right, and never through the plume.
3. What do you do about the combination of fatigue and the tailgating semi?
Read the worked answer
Fatigue is the hazard you cannot solve by technique, so it dictates the plan: the only real fix is to stop and rest or hand the wheel to someone else. Yawning repeatedly, gritty eyes and three hours at the wheel are signs of impairment that compare to alcohol in their effect on reaction time, and no amount of cold air or loud music reverses them. The semi changes where you can safely stop. Do not simply brake hard in front of it; signal early, slow gradually, and leave at a proper interchange or a plowed approach where you can pull fully off the travelled lane rather than parking on a shoulder with a truck bearing down at highway speed. Turning off the cruise control, slowing a little, and increasing the gap ahead buys margin in the meantime, and the game is not a reason to continue.