Two Boxes of Pseudoephedrine and a Brother Without ID
A 34-year-old man sets two 48-count boxes of 30 mg pseudoephedrine tablets on the counter at 10:15 a.m. and asks to pay cash. The technician checks the electronic log and finds the same man already recorded at 6:10 a.m. at the pharmacy across the street for two 48-count boxes of the same product. He explains that the first purchase was for his brother, who "doesn't carry ID," and that he is now buying for himself and a coworker. His driver's license is valid, shows he is 34, and the logging terminal is working normally. The pharmacist is asked to approve the transaction.
1. Calculate against the federal pseudoephedrine limits. May the pharmacy complete this sale?
Read the worked answer
Arithmetic: 48 tablets x 30 mg = 1,440 mg = 1.44 g per box. Two boxes = 2.88 g.
- Daily limit: 3.6 g per purchaser per day. With the 6:10 a.m. purchase of 2.88 g, this purchaser would reach 5.76 g in one day - over the limit. The maximum additional amount that could lawfully be sold today is 3.6 − 2.88 = 0.72 g, i.e. 24 tablets (half a box of this product, if the pharmacy can sell a partial box).
- 30-day limit: 9 g. Two such sales are already 5.76 g, leaving 3.24 g for the rest of the 30 days.
Because the pharmacy's electronic log is functioning, the earlier purchase is known and the sale as presented is not permitted. Selling the full two boxes would itself be a violation. Note also that the earlier purchase was admitted to be for another person, which makes the recorded log entry suspect and is a diversion red flag independent of the gram limits.
2. What entries and identification does the federal log requirement demand, and who may be recorded as the purchaser?
Read the worked answer
Before the sale, the pharmacy must:
- Require a photo ID and confirm the purchaser is at least 18 years old (this man qualifies).
- Record: product name, quantity sold, purchaser's name and address, date and time of sale, and the purchaser's signature; also record the type of identification and the ID number.
- Enter the sale into the electronic log before completing the transaction.
- Retain the records for 2 years and make them available for inspection.
The actual purchaser must sign - never the brother, the coworker, or whoever is said to be the end user. A customer who announces he is buying for other people is not a lawful purchaser for those units; the pharmacy should decline to log units attributed to a third party. This is precisely the pattern the log exists to break, and a signature swearing to a sale that is really for someone else is worse than refusing.
3. The customer becomes argumentative when told he can have only 24 tablets. How should the pharmacist handle the refusal and the record?
Read the worked answer
Safety first, then documentation - not disclosure.
- State the limit plainly (federal daily and 30-day caps) without accusing him of anything and without revealing that the pharmacy can see the other store's transaction (do not confirm or describe another pharmacy's records).
- Do not sell the excess. If he accepts 24 tablets, log and sell that quantity only; if he refuses, no sale and no log entry, because no pseudoephedrine left the pharmacy.
- Document internally: date, time, product, quantity requested, the reason for refusal (prior 2.88 g purchase today, purchase on behalf of others), and the pharmacist's initials. A short note in the pharmacy's incident/refusal file protects the pharmacist if the pattern repeats.
- Do not pursue, detain, or block the door. If the conduct becomes threatening, that is a security matter, not a pharmacy-law matter.
- A pharmacist may report suspicious purchasing patterns to law enforcement, but is not obligated to confront the customer about it at the counter.
The professionally defensible position is a clean refusal based on the gram limit, with the reasoning written down.