The Notary Who Is a Grantee
Robert is a Mississippi notary. His mother, who is 78, wants to deed her house to Robert and his two sisters as joint tenants with right of survivorship. She has already signed the deed in front of Robert's sister, and now Robert is asked to notarize the acknowledgment so the deed can be recorded before his mother enters the hospital. Robert is one of the grantees and will receive a one-third interest. His mother is alert and says she understands the deed. Robert's sister says it is fine because they are family. Robert has his seal and the deed has a blank notary acknowledgment. He wonders if he can notarize as long as he discloses the conflict in the certificate.
1. Can Robert notarize his mother's acknowledgment? Identify the disqualifying interest.
Read the worked answer
No. A notary may not perform a notarial act in which the notary is a party or has a direct beneficial interest. Robert is a grantee and will receive a one-third interest in the house, so he has a direct financial interest in the deed. Disclosure in the certificate does not cure the conflict; the certificate would still be performed by an interested notary. The mother's alertness and family consent do not change the rule. Robert should decline and arrange for an independent notary, preferably one who can travel to the mother, to take the acknowledgment.
2. If Robert's mother had signed the deed before Robert arrived, would that change the analysis?
Read the worked answer
It would not cure the conflict. An acknowledgment can occur after the signer has signed, if the signer personally appears before the notary and acknowledges the signature. But Robert's direct interest still disqualifies him. If there were no conflict, the notary could acknowledge the signature after the fact, provided the mother appeared, was competent, and was properly identified. Here, the prior signing and the sister's presence do not make Robert an eligible notary, and the sister's witness does not substitute for the mother's acknowledgment before an independent notary.
3. What risks and practical steps should Robert consider?
Read the worked answer
A deed notarized by an interested notary may be challenged, rejected for recording, or set aside, and Robert could face administrative discipline and civil liability. The family may also face disputes about undue influence, especially given the mother's upcoming hospitalization. Robert should not use his seal, should not make a false journal entry, and should not pressure his mother. He should refer the matter to an independent notary or attorney, preserve the document as signed, and let the mother obtain independent advice if there is any question about her understanding or intent.