Experience Is Not a Certificate: Instructor Credentials at Two Mines
A company owns an underground coal mine covered by Part 48 and a nearby sand and gravel pit covered by Part 46. The coal mine's safety officer, Dana, has 15 years of underground experience and a state mining certificate, but she is not on MSHA's approved instructor list. The company wants Dana to teach the annual refresher at both sites next month because the regular instructor is unavailable. At the sand and gravel pit, plant superintendent Luis has eight years of experience and a 30-hour OSHA course; he is not MSHA-approved either. The training budget is tight. The owner asks whether Dana and Luis can legally deliver the eight-hour refresher. The coal mine's Part 48 plan names Dana as training coordinator; the sand and gravel plan names Luis as a competent person. No MSHA approval letters for either individual are on file.
1. Can Dana deliver the Part 48 annual refresher? What must be true for her to instruct?
Read the worked answer
Dana cannot deliver the Part 48 annual refresher unless she is an MSHA-approved instructor. Part 48 requires training to be conducted by instructors approved by MSHA; 15 years of experience and a state certificate do not substitute for that approval. Being named training coordinator in the plan does not make her an approved instructor. The operator must either use an MSHA-approved instructor or apply to have Dana approved before the class. If she teaches without approval, the training may not count and the operator risks a citation.
2. Can Luis deliver the Part 46 refresher? What standard applies?
Read the worked answer
Luis may deliver the Part 46 refresher if he is a competent person for the subjects taught. Part 46 does not require MSHA-approved instructors; it requires a competent person with the knowledge, training, and experience to instruct and evaluate miners. The 30-hour OSHA course is not an MSHA credential, but it can be part of the documentation. Luis must be listed in the Part 46 plan and should be able to show why he is competent for each topic. If a topic is outside his competence, another competent person should teach it.
3. What are the consequences if Dana teaches the coal mine refresher without approval?
Read the worked answer
If Dana teaches the coal mine refresher without MSHA approval, MSHA could cite the operator for failing to use approved instructors, and the miners' refresher records could be challenged. The operator may have to repeat the training with an approved instructor. Because annual refresher is required, miners who did not receive valid training could be considered overdue, and MSHA could order them removed from the mine until trained. The cheaper short-term choice creates a larger compliance and production risk.