Two Servers Down on a Fully Booked Birthday Friday
An 80-seat à la carte restaurant has 58 reservations for Friday dinner, including a table of 10 for a 70th birthday at 19:30 and two tables of four in quiet corners. At 17:00 two of the five servers call in sick; the restaurant also has one host, one bartender, three kitchen staff, and a trainee who has completed two weeks. Last Friday's POS shows 14 walk-ins between 18:00 and 20:00. The birthday group has pre-ordered two platters and a cake that must be served at 21:00. The service standard is 15 minutes to first drink and 45 minutes from order to main. The kitchen can produce a maximum of 24 main courses an hour when three cooks work the line. The manager must decide whether to keep all reservations or cap bookings, and how to pace the room.
1. Decide how many covers to accept and produce a pacing plan from 18:00 to 21:00. Justify using server capacity, kitchen output and the birthday commitment.
Read the worked answer
Keep the 58 reservations and cap walk-ins at about 6 until 20:00, rather than accepting all 14. Three servers plus a host and trainee can handle about 54–60 covers if the menu is limited; the kitchen maximum is 24 mains per hour, so 58 covers across three hours is feasible only if seating is staggered. Pacing plan:
- 18:00: 14 covers
- 18:15: 10 covers
- 18:30: 12 covers
- 19:00: 8 covers
- 19:30: birthday 10 covers
- 20:00: 4 covers from the waitlist Total = 58. Set the birthday table by 19:15 and assign one server to it from 19:15 to 21:00. Hold the two quiet four-tops for the guests who requested them. The host manages the waitlist and drinks; the bartender supports drinks; the trainee clears, waters and resets only. Justification: cancelling reservations damages trust and revenue, while accepting 14 walk-ins would push covers per server above 24 and break the 45-minute main-course standard. Capping walk-ins protects the birthday commitment and kitchen flow.
2. Write the message to the birthday host and the walk-in policy you would instruct the host to use. Include how you protect the 21:00 cake service.
Read the worked answer
Message to the birthday host, by 17:30: 'Good evening. Two servers are off sick tonight, so we are running a limited menu and pacing tables carefully. Your table for 10 is confirmed at 19:30, the two platters are on order, and the cake will be served at 21:00 as planned. To keep timing, may I take your main-course choices now? I will assign a dedicated server to your party from 19:15.' Walk-in policy for the host: quote 25–35 minutes, take a mobile number, offer the bar, and do not guarantee a table before 20:30. Seat only 6 walk-ins before 20:00. Protect the cake by storing it in the fridge, setting a 20:50 reminder, assigning the dedicated server, and holding a clean knife and plates. Do not let the birthday table wait for the cake because of a late main course.
3. At 20:10, mains are taking 38 minutes and the birthday platters are not ready. Identify three control actions and one metric you would monitor for the rest of service.
Read the worked answer
Actions:
- Stop seating new walk-ins and ask the host to quote a longer wait. This reduces the kitchen queue.
- Ask the kitchen to sequence the birthday platters next and give the manager a realistic time. Send bread, olives or a small apology item to the birthday table.
- Reassign the trainee to clearing and resetting so servers stay on the floor, and have the host update waiting guests every 10 minutes. Metric: order-to-main ticket time, with a target of 45 minutes or less. Also watch covers seated per 15 minutes and any table waiting more than 60 minutes. If ticket time passes 50 minutes, stop all seating until it falls, and record the delay for the duty manager.