The Daughter Who Wants Everything Done
Mr. Delgado, 78, has metastatic pancreatic cancer and a signed physician order for comfort-focused care. His daughter Elena, who holds his durable power of attorney for health care, arrives at 7 a.m. after a night shift and finds him drowsy on scheduled morphine. She demands that the aide, Priya, stop the morphine, sit him up in the chair for breakfast, and call 911 if he "looks bad." Mr. Delgado is alert enough to say, "I'm tired, honey, let me sleep" when she shakes his shoulder. His respirations are 20 and regular, pulse oximetry 91% on room air, and he winces when repositioned. Elena tells Priya, "If you don't help him eat, I'll report you for neglect." Priya has 30 minutes before her next assigned patient.
1. What should Priya do first, and what should she not do?
Read the worked answer
First: Stop and acknowledge Elena's fear without agreeing to the unsafe requests. Say something like, "You're scared he's giving up. I hear that." Then state the facts plainly: the morphine is ordered to treat his pain and air hunger, and withholding it would cause suffering, not comfort.
Do not: Wake him for a chair or a meal he has declined, or call 911 for expected end-of-life changes. Do not argue about the neglect threat or defend yourself.
Why: The aide's scope is to follow the comfort care plan and report changes. Refusing to force food or reposition a sleeping, comfortable patient is not neglect; it is honoring the plan of care and the patient's own stated wish. A 911 call for expected dying signs would trigger unwanted interventions and is outside the aide's role. Acknowledge, inform, and escalate - don't comply and don't fight.
2. Elena's threat to report neglect and her request to reverse the plan of care conflict. How should Priya respond and to whom should she report?
Read the worked answer
Respond: "I can't change his plan, and I won't stop medicine that keeps him comfortable. I'll get the nurse and the social worker so we can talk together about what you're seeing."
Report to: the RN case manager immediately (before leaving the room if possible), plus the interdisciplinary team - social worker and chaplain - for a family meeting. Document the conversation objectively: what Elena said, what the patient said, what Priya did.
Why: Threats and family conflict are RN/team-level issues. The aide's job is to keep care consistent and not be bullied into unsafe actions. A team response also protects Priya from a false allegation, because the record shows she escalated promptly and followed the plan. If Elena does file a complaint, the documentation of the patient's own words ("let me sleep") supports the aide.
3. The patient is drowsy and his oxygen reads 91%. Should Priya reposition him, and how does she decide?
Read the worked answer
Decide by comfort, not by numbers. He winced when repositioned, so a full turn for routine skin care is not automatically indicated. Offer a gentle side-lying position with pillows for support, or leave him if he is settled and pain-free. Reassess his face and breathing, not just the monitor.
Oxygen 91%: In comfort-focused hospice care, a sat of 91% on room air in a dying patient is expected and is not itself a reason to intervene. Treat distress (air hunger, grimacing, restlessness), not the number.
Report: Tell the RN that he is drowsy, that he winced on movement, and that Elena is requesting changes. The RN decides whether the morphine schedule or positioning plan needs adjustment. Priya does not change the plan herself.