The Family That Wants to Be There at the End
Mr. and Mrs. Haddad have three adult children. Mr. Haddad, 76, has end-stage heart failure and is actively dying in a hospice inpatient unit. His breathing is irregular with long pauses, his hands are cool and mottled, and he has not been responsive since morning. The eldest son, Karim, insists on staying at the bedside and asks the aide, Lena, to "keep checking he's still breathing" every few minutes. The younger daughter, Amira, wants to be alone with him and asks Lena to keep everyone out. The family is Muslim; Karim has asked that his father be positioned facing Mecca and that no one "give up on him." A cousin is loudly praying in the hallway. Lena has 20 minutes before shift change.
1. How should Lena respond to Karim's request to check breathing every few minutes?
Read the worked answer
Respond with reassurance and a boundary: "He's comfortable. I'll check on him regularly, and I'll tell you right away if anything changes. You don't have to watch every breath - you can hold his hand and talk to him."
Do not: stand at the bedside checking every few minutes, which fuels anxiety and pulls Lena from other duties.
Why: Frequent breath-checking increases the family's fear and does not change care. A predictable check schedule plus honest communication is more supportive. Lena reports the irregular breathing to the RN as part of her assessment, not as a favor to the son.
2. Amira wants to be alone with her father; Karim wants the family present. How does Lena handle this conflict?
Read the worked answer
Do not take sides. Acknowledge both: "You both love him and want to be with him. Let's find a way that works for everyone."
Practical steps:
- Offer a rotation: Amira has private time now; Karim and the cousin come in after.
- Ask the RN or social worker to help mediate if the conflict escalates.
- Keep the cousin's praying respectful of other patients - offer a quiet space or ask the family to lower the volume.
Why: The aide's role is to support family presence, not to referee. A rotation honors both needs. Escalating to the team is appropriate when conflict affects care or other patients. Document what was agreed.
3. Karim asks that his father face Mecca and says no one should "give up." What is within Lena's role, and what must she clarify?
Read the worked answer
Within role:
- Position him gently to face Mecca if it can be done without causing pain or distress, and if the RN's plan allows repositioning. Many dying patients can be turned slightly; comfort comes first.
- Respect religious practices: allow prayer, keep the environment calm, do not interrupt rituals unnecessarily.
- Ask the family what matters most to them and pass it to the team.
Clarify: "Giving up" likely means stopping treatments. Lena should explain that comfort care is active care - it treats pain, breathlessness, and fear - and that the RN and physician can talk with the family about what is and is not being done.
Why: Honoring religious and cultural needs is part of patient- and family-centered care. But Lena does not decide on treatments or make promises. She supports the practice, reports the request, and lets the team address the fear behind "giving up."