The Client Who Wants to Talk About Her Marriage
Lena, 41, came to coaching for 'stress and eating habits.' In session three she begins crying and describes her marriage as 'falling apart.' She says her husband has been drinking heavily, has become verbally harsh, and that she 'doesn't know what to do.' She asks you, 'What would you do? Should I leave?' She also says she has not told anyone else. She has a 9-year-old daughter. She denies any physical violence but says he has 'thrown things' twice in the last month. She wants to keep the conversation between the two of you.
1. What is the coach's immediate obligation in this session?
Read the worked answer
The coach's first obligation is safety and scope. Verbal harshness plus throwing objects is a pattern the coach should not treat as ordinary relationship coaching material. The coach acknowledges Lena's distress, thanks her for trusting the coach, and is honest about role limits: 'I'm glad you told me. I'm not the right person to help you decide about your marriage, and I want to make sure you have someone who is.'
The coach asks directly and calmly about safety for Lena and her daughter - whether either has been hurt, whether there are weapons in the home, whether she has a safe place to go. The coach does not press for details Lena does not want to give.
The coach provides or offers to help her find appropriate resources: a domestic violence hotline, a therapist, legal aid. If there is imminent danger, the coach supports her in contacting emergency services. The coach does not promise confidentiality that the coach cannot keep.
2. Lena asks, 'Should I leave?' How does the coach respond?
Read the worked answer
The coach does not answer the question. That is not evasion; it is the correct boundary. The decision belongs to Lena, and a coach's opinion would carry weight the coach is not qualified to hold.
A useful response: 'I'm not going to tell you what to do - that's not my call, and you're the one who has to live with it. What I can do is help you think about what you need and who can help you figure it out.' The coach can then support practical next steps: talking to a therapist, calling a hotline to understand options, identifying a safe place, thinking through what she would need to feel ready.
The coach should also name that the coach is not a therapist or a lawyer and that these questions deserve those professionals. That is not rejection; it is directing her to the right help.
3. Lena says she wants the conversation kept between the two of you. What does the coach say?
Read the worked answer
The coach should be honest about the limits of confidentiality at the outset of coaching and again here. The coach does not promise to keep secret anything that involves risk of harm to Lena or her daughter.
A clear response: 'What you tell me stays between us in most cases - but I can't promise that if I believe you or your daughter are in danger. In that situation I'd talk with you first about what to do next.' The coach should not threaten to report without context, and should not promise secrecy the coach cannot keep.
The coach should also be clear about what the coach will and will not do: the coach is not a mandated reporter in every jurisdiction for every situation, but the coach does have a duty to act on serious safety concerns. The coach should know the applicable rules for their location and should say plainly what those rules mean for this conversation.