Permit, Contract, and Change-Order Judgment on a Duct Replacement
A contractor signs a fixed-price contract to replace a residential duct system for $9,500, including permits, labor, and materials. The contract states the work will be completed in five working days and that the contractor will obtain all required permits. During demolition, the crew finds the existing return trunk is wrapped in damaged material that may contain asbestos, and the supply trunk passes through a wall that requires a fire-rated penetration seal not included in the original scope. The homeowner asks the contractor to proceed without a permit to save time because a neighbor had work done without one. The contractor has already ordered $3,200 in materials and scheduled two crew members for the week.
1. Evaluate the homeowner's request to skip the permit and explain the contractor's obligations.
Read the worked answer
The contractor must decline. The contract states the contractor will obtain all required permits, and mechanical work of this scope generally requires a permit under the state mechanical code. Proceeding without one exposes the contractor to:
- Code enforcement action, stop-work orders, and fines.
- Licensing board discipline, since unpermitted work can be treated as a licensing violation.
- Liability if the work fails inspection or causes damage; insurance may deny claims for unpermitted work.
- Contract breach, since the contract expressly promises permits.
The neighbor's experience is not a defense. The contractor should explain the risk to the homeowner in writing and proceed with the permit.
2. The asbestos-suspect material and the fire-rated penetration are discovered conditions. How should the contractor handle scope, cost, and schedule?
Read the worked answer
Both are changed conditions not included in the original scope, so they should be handled through a written change order before work continues.
- Asbestos-suspect material: stop work in that area, do not disturb it, and have it tested by a qualified party. If confirmed, abatement must be performed by qualified personnel before the crew proceeds. This is a schedule and cost impact.
- Fire-rated penetration: the seal is required by code and was not in the original scope. Price the seal and include it in the change order.
The contractor should document the conditions with photos, issue a written change order with cost and time impact, and obtain the homeowner's written approval before performing the added work. Proceeding without a change order risks an unpaid claim and a dispute.
3. The homeowner refuses the change order and demands the original price and schedule. What are the contractor's options?
Read the worked answer
The contractor should not perform the added work for free, and should not proceed with unsafe or non-compliant work.
Options:
- Explain that the added work is outside the contract scope and is required by code or safety; the original price did not include it.
- Offer to proceed with the original scope only where it is safe and compliant, and suspend work in the affected areas until the change order is resolved.
- If the homeowner refuses, the contractor may terminate or suspend the contract for changed conditions, documenting the refusal in writing.
- Seek mediation or legal advice if the dispute continues.
The contractor should avoid abandoning the job in a way that leaves an unsafe condition. The priority is a written record of the refusal, a safe jobsite, and compliance with code and licensing obligations.