The LLC Draws, the Silent Operating Agreement, and the Supplier Demand
Two friends, Maya and Dev, form a North Carolina LLC called Triangle Fresh LLC to operate a meal-prep kitchen. Maya contributes $60,000 cash; Dev contributes equipment worth $15,000 and full-time management. Their operating agreement says only that profits and losses are split "as the members agree" and is silent on salaries, distributions, deadlock, and withdrawal. After 18 months, the LLC owes $42,000 to a food supplier. Maya has received no distributions, but Dev has taken $3,500 per month as a "draw" without a member vote. Maya wants to dissolve the LLC and recover her capital. Dev says the draws were salary and refuses. The supplier has demanded payment and threatens suit. The LLC's bank account has $8,200. The operating agreement requires amendments in writing signed by both members. Maya calls the firm.
1. How should the firm analyze whether Dev's $3,500 monthly draws were authorized distributions or unauthorized compensation?
Read the worked answer
Start with the operating agreement. It is silent on salaries and distributions, so the default rules of the North Carolina LLC Act, Chapter 57D, fill the gaps. The firm should determine whether the draws were treated as distributions of profit, compensation for services, or repayments of capital. Request the bank statements, general ledger, tax returns, K-1s, member meeting minutes, and any texts or emails in which Maya agreed to the draws. Under the default rules, management and distribution decisions may require member action, and distributions must be allocated according to the statute and the members' contributions unless the operating agreement provides otherwise.
If Dev took money without authority and beyond his distributive share, Maya may have a claim for an accounting, breach of fiduciary duty, or unjust enrichment. If Maya knowingly acquiesced for 18 months, Dev may argue an implied agreement or waiver. Do not assume a 50/50 split or that "draw" means salary. Also separate the LLC's $42,000 supplier debt from the members' personal liability: members are not personally liable solely because they are members, but a personal guaranty or alter ego theory could change that.
2. Can Maya dissolve Triangle Fresh LLC unilaterally, and what steps should she take?
Read the worked answer
Not automatically. Because the operating agreement is silent, the default dissolution and dissociation provisions of Chapter 57D control. A member generally cannot dissolve an LLC merely by announcing it; dissolution may require member consent, a specified event, or a court order. Maya should first send a written demand for records, an accounting, and a member meeting. If Dev refuses, she may negotiate a buyout or seek judicial dissolution on deadlock or oppression grounds, depending on the statutory standard and the facts. She should not drain the $8,200 bank account or transfer LLC assets, because that could expose her to liability and undermine her position.
The firm should also review whether Maya's withdrawal would be wrongful dissociation and whether the supplier debt must be addressed in winding up. Any dissolution requires notice to creditors, payment of liabilities, and articles of dissolution after proper authorization. The paralegal can prepare the demand letter, records request, and chronology, but the attorney must advise on the statutory grounds and negotiate with Dev's counsel.
3. What provisions should be added to a revised operating agreement to prevent a recurrence?
Read the worked answer
The agreement should define capital contributions, capital accounts, distributions, salaries, and expense reimbursements separately. It should state how profits and losses are allocated, when distributions are mandatory or discretionary, and whether member approval is required for draws above a set amount. Add a deadlock provision, such as mediation or a buy-sell mechanism, and a dissociation and buyout formula. Include dissolution triggers, winding-up procedures, records rights, bank-signature authority, and a requirement that all amendments be written and signed. Also address personal guaranties and supplier credit so members know when they are accepting personal liability. The paralegal can prepare a comparison chart of the current agreement and the proposed provisions, but the attorney should counsel both members and confirm that Maya and Dev each have independent advice or a written conflict waiver before signing.