The Will with One Signature, the Caregiver Gift, and the Capacity Challenge
Eighty-two-year-old Walter Grant asks your firm to probate a will he signed six weeks ago. The will leaves his $860,000 estate: $500,000 to his daughter, Karen; $250,000 to his son, Todd; and $110,000 to his caregiver, Maria. Walter's longtime attorney drafted the will, but the signing took place at Walter's kitchen table. The will is signed by Walter and contains attestation language for two witnesses. Only one witness, a neighbor, signed; the second witness, Maria's husband, signed a separate self-proving affidavit but did not sign the will. Walter now says he wants to "make it right" because Karen is upset. The original will is in the firm's vault. Walter's capacity is questioned by Todd, who says Walter has short-term memory loss. The clerk requires a probate filing within 30 days of the application. The firm's paralegal is asked to prepare the petition and advise Walter.
1. Is the will validly executed under North Carolina law, and what should the firm do before filing?
Read the worked answer
The will is probably not validly executed. North Carolina law requires the testator to sign the will and at least two competent witnesses to attest and sign in the testator's presence. Only one witness signed the will itself. Maria's husband signed a separate self-proving affidavit, but a self-proving affidavit is not a substitute for the attestation clause and witness signatures on the will. The affidavit can simplify probate only if the will was properly executed in the first place.
Because Walter is alive, the firm should not file an invalid will. It should draft a new will or codicil, arrange execution with two independent witnesses who are not beneficiaries or spouses of beneficiaries, and complete a self-proving affidavit at the same time. Maria's husband is a poor witness because of Maria's $110,000 gift. The paralegal may prepare the drafts and the execution checklist under attorney supervision, but the attorney must supervise the signing and confirm Walter's intent. If Walter dies before re-execution, the estate may pass under an earlier will or intestacy, so preserve the original and document the defect.
2. How should the firm address the capacity and undue influence concerns?
Read the worked answer
Capacity and undue influence are separate issues. Capacity asks whether Walter understands the nature of the act, the extent of his property, the natural objects of his bounty, and the disposition he is making. Undue influence asks whether Maria or someone else substituted her will for his. Todd's report of short-term memory loss is a warning sign but not a diagnosis. The attorney should meet Walter alone, ask open-ended questions about his family, assets, and reasons for the gift to Maria, and document his answers. If there is genuine doubt, obtain a medical evaluation before signing.
The $110,000 caregiver gift and the involvement of Maria's husband create a challenge risk. Use independent witnesses, consider a video recording of the execution, and prepare a contemporaneous capacity memo. Do not let Karen pressure Walter to change the will during the meeting. If Walter lacks capacity, he cannot execute a new will, and the firm should discuss alternatives such as guardianship with the attorney. The paralegal should not make the capacity judgment or give Walter legal advice.
3. What probate and office-practice steps follow if a valid will is signed?
Read the worked answer
After a valid execution, the original should be returned to the vault and logged with the date, witnesses, and self-proving affidavit. The paralegal should prepare a probate checklist and calendar the clerk's 30-day filing requirement from the application date. On Walter's death, the petition for probate will need the original will, death certificate, names and addresses of heirs, and a preliminary estimate of assets. The personal representative will also need to file an inventory within the statutory period after qualification and provide notice to creditors and heirs.
Office practice should include a conflict check, a client communication file, and a clear record of who witnessed and notarized the documents. The paralegal may prepare the petition and correspondence under attorney supervision but may not advise Walter on the legal effect of the will or represent the estate in court. If Todd contests, preserve all drafts, notes, and execution-day records and route the matter to the attorney immediately.