Fifteen-Year-Old Driver With an Injured Passenger
At 12:40 a.m. on a rural two-lane road in Johnston County, you stop a compact car for weaving and a broken taillight. The driver is a 15-year-old boy; the passenger is a 14-year-old girl. The boy says he took his mother's car without permission to get the girl away from a party where older teens were drinking. There is an open bottle of vodka on the rear floorboard and the girl has a bruised wrist. The boy is calm and asks if he can just drive home; the girl is crying and says she does not want her parents called. The car is registered to the boy's mother, who does not answer her phone. Your dispatcher confirms no warrants and no missing-person report. The nearest juvenile detention facility is 45 minutes away; a parent or guardian must be contacted.
1. Do you have legal authority to take the 15-year-old driver into custody, and what factors determine whether you should?
Read the worked answer
You have probable cause for traffic offenses and evidence of underage alcohol possession, but custody of a juvenile is a separate decision from probable cause. Under North Carolina juvenile law, a 15-year-old is within juvenile jurisdiction for these alleged offenses; you should not process him as an adult or place him in adult detention. Before taking physical custody, weigh immediate safety: the girl has a bruised wrist, the boy took the car without permission, and no parent is answering. The least restrictive option consistent with safety is usually to contact a parent or guardian and release the juvenile to that person with a citation or juvenile petition, unless the child is a danger to self or others or likely to flee.
If the mother cannot be reached, follow juvenile intake procedures and contact DSS or the juvenile court counselor rather than driving 45 minutes to detention without authorization. Document the efforts to reach a guardian, the girl's injury, and the boy's statements. Do not let the boy drive away without a licensed adult. Arrange transport or release only after a guardian is located and the girl's welfare is addressed.
2. Can you question the boy about taking the car and the alcohol before his mother arrives?
Read the worked answer
Do not conduct a custodial interrogation of the 15-year-old before a parent or guardian is present, and do not treat his calm demeanor as a waiver of that protection. Ask only the questions necessary to identify him, determine immediate medical needs, and locate a guardian. If he volunteers statements, you may listen and document them, but do not use follow-up questions designed to elicit incriminating details about taking the car, the vodka, or the party.
Once a guardian arrives, any interview should be recorded and should include an explanation of the juvenile's rights in language he understands. The parent's presence does not automatically make a waiver valid; consider the juvenile's age, education, and whether the waiver is knowing and voluntary. If the boy asks for a lawyer or a parent, stop questioning. Document the time questioning stopped and the circumstances. The alcohol and unauthorized-use issues can be addressed through the juvenile petition and intake process after the guardian is notified.
3. The girl has a bruised wrist and refuses to call her parents. How should you handle her welfare and the notification question?
Read the worked answer
The bruised wrist and her statement that she was at a party with older teens drinking create a child-welfare concern that is separate from the traffic stop. Separate her from the boy, ask open-ended questions about how she was injured, and offer EMS evaluation. Do not pressure her to call her parents, but do not promise confidentiality you cannot keep. If she discloses abuse or neglect, or if the bruise is unexplained and concerning, make a report to DSS consistent with mandatory-reporting duties.
Attempt to notify her parent or guardian through dispatch using the information available. If no guardian can be reached and she is not safe to release, follow juvenile custody and DSS procedures. She should not be left with the 15-year-old driver or allowed to walk away at night. Document her statements, the appearance of the bruise, the EMS response, and every notification attempt. The boy's decision to remove her from the party may be relevant to disposition, but it does not override the need to assess her safety and notify a responsible adult.