Off-Center Lift of a Valve Spool
A 24-ft, 10-inch Schedule 40 carbon steel spool is being lifted from a pipe rack to an elevated rack. The spool has a 10-inch gate valve flanged on one end and a blind flange on the other. The pipe weighs about 40.5 lb/ft, the valve weighs about 300 lb, and flanges and bolts add about 80 lb. The center of gravity is roughly 6 ft from the valve end. Two lifting lugs are welded 2 ft and 18 ft from the valve end. The rigger plans a two-leg bridle at 60° from horizontal with a tag line. The slings are rated 1,000 lb vertical each. The lift is 18 ft high with workers below. You are asked to review the lift.
1. Estimate the spool weight and the tension in each sling leg if the CG were centered.
Read the worked answer
Pipe weight = 24 ft × 40.5 lb/ft = 972 lb. Add the valve, 300 lb, and flanges/bolts, 80 lb: total = 1,352 lb, about 1,350 lb. If the CG were centered and the two legs were at 60° from horizontal, each leg would carry half the vertical load: 1,350/2 = 675 lb vertical. Tension = vertical load / sin 60° = 675/0.866 = 779 lb per leg. That is below the 1,000-lb vertical rating, but this is only a check; the actual CG is not centered, and the sling rating must be adjusted for the hitch and angle. The 60° angle increases tension compared with a vertical lift, so never use the vertical rating without checking tension.
2. The CG is 6 ft from the valve end. Calculate the actual leg tensions and decide whether the lift is acceptable.
Read the worked answer
Take the valve end as zero. Lugs are at 2 ft and 18 ft, so the span is 16 ft. The CG is at 6 ft, which is 4 ft from the left lug and 12 ft from the right lug. The left lug reaction is 1,350 × 12/16 = 1,013 lb; the right lug reaction is 1,350 × 4/16 = 338 lb. Convert to sling tension at 60°: left = 1,013/0.866 = 1,170 lb; right = 338/0.866 = 390 lb. The left sling is over its 1,000-lb rating, so the lift as planned is not acceptable. The spool will also hang with the valve end low because the CG is closer to the left lug. Reposition the lugs, use a spreader beam or an equalizing sling with a sliding choker, or use higher-rated slings. Recalculate before lifting.
3. What other rigging checks would you require?
Read the worked answer
Verify the actual weight from the pipe schedule and valve tag, not just the estimate. Inspect slings, shackles, and lifting lugs for cracks, wear, and proper welds; the lugs must be rated for the load and attached by a qualified welder. Use softeners or protectors where slings contact the pipe. Attach a tag line to control rotation, and keep workers out from under the load. Check the lift path for overhead obstructions and the landing rack for capacity. Use a spotter and a pre-lift meeting. If the load must be leveled, do it with an adjustable sling before lifting, not by a worker holding the load. After lifting a few inches, stop and check for tipping, sling slip, and lug movement.