Reasonable Accommodation for an Emotional Support Animal in a Four-Unit Rental
Landlord owns a four-unit apartment building. Tenant has lived in Unit 2 for three years and pays $1,200 monthly. The lease says no pets. The building is subject to HOA covenants that also prohibit pets. Tenant has anxiety and asks Landlord to waive the no-pet rule so Tenant can keep a 20-pound dog as an emotional support animal. Tenant provides a note from a licensed therapist stating that Tenant has anxiety and that an emotional support animal 'would be beneficial.' The note does not say Tenant is disabled, does not describe tasks the dog performs, and is not from a treating physician. Landlord asks for more information, including whether Tenant is under professional care and how the animal helps. Tenant refuses, says the note is enough, and files a fair housing complaint. Landlord comes to your firm for an objective memo. The file includes the lease, HOA covenants, the therapist's note, and emails. Landlord has never seen the dog act aggressively; no other tenant has complained.
1. What legal standard governs Tenant's request for an emotional support animal?
Read the worked answer
The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on disability, including refusal to make a reasonable accommodation. An emotional support animal is an accommodation, not a service animal, so the ADA's service-animal rules do not control. Tenant must show (1) a disability, meaning a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity, and (2) a disability-related need for the animal. The therapist's note says Tenant has anxiety and that an ESA 'would be beneficial,' but it does not state that Tenant is substantially limited in a major life activity or explain how the dog helps. A bare claim of benefit is weaker than a statement of need. Landlord must engage in an interactive process and cannot simply deny the request. The HOA covenant does not override the FHA; if the accommodation is reasonable, Landlord may need to seek a waiver or exception.
2. May Landlord require additional documentation from Tenant?
Read the worked answer
Landlord may request additional documentation when the disability or need is not obvious. The FHA does not require Landlord to accept a note that fails to establish disability or need. Landlord may ask for reliable documentation from a treating professional-such as a physician, therapist, or social worker-that confirms Tenant has a disability and explains how the animal provides support. Landlord should not demand a specific diagnosis or ask for unnecessary medical records. The request should be tailored and reasonable. Tenant's refusal to provide more information does not automatically defeat the request, but it may justify delay while Landlord seeks clarification. Landlord should document the interactive process. If Tenant later provides sufficient information, Landlord must grant the accommodation unless it would impose an undue financial or administrative burden or pose a direct threat.
3. Does the HOA no-pet covenant affect the analysis, and what should Landlord do?
Read the worked answer
The HOA no-pet covenant does not give Landlord a defense under the FHA. Federal fair housing law preempts conflicting private covenants when a reasonable accommodation is required. Landlord may have to seek a variance from the HOA or, if the HOA refuses, argue that the FHA requires an exception. The covenant may still be relevant to whether the accommodation is reasonable and whether Landlord can practically grant it, but it cannot be the sole basis for denial. Landlord should also consider whether the dog poses a direct threat or would cause substantial damage; there is no evidence of aggression, and no other tenant has complained. A 20-pound dog in a four-unit building is unlikely to be an undue burden. Landlord should grant the accommodation if Tenant provides adequate documentation, or risk a fair housing complaint and damages.