Underwriting a High-Risk Commercial Risk
A new nightclub applies for commercial combined cover: buildings £1.2m, contents £300,000, public liability £5m, employers' liability £10m. The risk has:
- capacity 600 people, open until 3am, seven nights a week;
- a history of two fire-related incidents in the last five years (one kitchen fire, one electrical fault);
- no sprinkler system, but a monitored alarm and emergency lighting;
- a previous insurer declined to renew after a serious assault claim;
- the owner has 15 years' experience and has introduced door staff, CCTV and a drugs policy.
The underwriter must decide whether to quote, decline, or offer terms with conditions, and at what premium.
1. Identify the key underwriting factors and recommend a decision.
Read the worked answer
Key factors:
- Fire risk: two incidents in five years is a poor claims history; no sprinklers in a 600-capacity late-night venue is a significant hazard. Monitored alarm and emergency lighting mitigate but do not remove the risk.
- Liability risk: the previous assault claim and late licence increase exposure; £5m public liability is high for a nightclub.
- Management quality: 15 years' experience, door staff, CCTV and a drugs policy are strong positives - management is often the best predictor of loss.
- Occupancy and hours: 3am closing and 600 capacity increase both fire and liability exposure.
Recommendation: do not decline outright. Offer terms with conditions:
- install sprinklers within 12 months (or a premium loading until then);
- maintain door staff and CCTV, with records;
- a higher excess for fire and assault claims;
- a reduced public liability limit (e.g. £2m) unless justified;
- a premium loading reflecting the claims history and the previous declinature.
Refer to a senior underwriter because of the previous declinature and the £5m limit. Document the rationale.
2. How should the underwriter handle the previous declinature fairly and lawfully?
Read the worked answer
- Ask about it on the proposal form and in a fair, non-discriminatory way; do not use it as an automatic bar.
- Consider the reason for the declinature - was it the assault claim, poor management, or something now remedied?
- Avoid unfair discrimination - decisions must be based on risk factors, not protected characteristics.
- Explain the decision to the applicant if declined or loaded, so they understand what would make them insurable.
- Record the reasoning for audit and complaints purposes.
A previous declinature is relevant but not determinative: the underwriter must assess the current risk on its merits.