Infant with fractures and an inconsistent history: reporting while caring
You are caring for a 5-month-old boy brought to the emergency department at 22:00 by his mother's boyfriend. The boyfriend says the baby 'rolled off the couch' while he was in the kitchen making a bottle. Triage notes bruising to the left cheek and right upper arm. The infant is alert, feeds eagerly from a bottle, and has a soft, flat anterior fontanelle. X-ray shows a healing posterior rib fracture on the right and a spiral fracture of the right humerus. According to the mother, who arrived 20 minutes later, the baby cannot roll yet and she works nights, leaving the baby with her boyfriend. The boyfriend has answered most questions and corrects the mother when she gives a different time line. The mother asks, 'Do you have to call anyone? Can we just go home?'
1. What are the nurse's legal and safety obligations, and what must the nurse avoid doing?
Read the worked answer
The nurse must report a reasonable suspicion of child abuse to child protective services under state law and facility policy. The standard is suspicion, not proof; the nurse does not need to identify the perpetrator or confront the family. Posterior rib fractures and a spiral humerus fracture in a 5-month-old who cannot roll, with bruising and an inconsistent history, meet that threshold. Immediately ensure the infant's safety, notify the attending physician and social work, and complete the required report. Arrange the medical evaluation the team orders, which may include a skeletal survey and head and eye examination. Do not let the infant leave before medical clearance; if the family tries to leave, follow policy and involve security and the reporting agency. Do not conduct an investigative interview, repeatedly question the family, or accuse anyone, because that can contaminate the evidence and endanger the child. Preserve the record and any items per policy, and continue feeding, comforting, and routine care.
2. How do you communicate with the mother and boyfriend while the evaluation continues?
Read the worked answer
Be calm, nonjudgmental, and honest without disclosing the report details: 'We're concerned because these injuries don't match the story and because a baby this age can't roll. We're following our child-protection process, and our first job is to keep him safe.' Explain what will happen next and who will be involved, and tell the mother she can stay with the baby. Avoid blaming, interrogating, or asking leading questions; ask open-ended questions about the baby's history, feeding, and who provides care, and document the answers verbatim. Acknowledge the mother's fear and the possibility that she is being coerced or controlled by the boyfriend, and offer social work and a private space. Do not promise that no report will be made or that they can go home. Keep the infant in sight, limit the number of staff handling him, and maintain a calm, caring environment for the baby.
3. What documentation is required, and why does it matter?
Read the worked answer
Document objectively: who brought the infant, the exact stated mechanism and time, who gave the history, and direct quotations of discrepancies. Record the developmental stage, including that the baby cannot roll, and describe each injury with size, color, location, and a body diagram. Include the imaging results, who was notified, the time the report was made, the agency and person contacted, and the safety plan. Avoid conclusions such as naming a perpetrator; record facts and observations instead. Note the questions asked and the answers given, without editorializing. Complete the report per policy and retain the required copy. Accurate, contemporaneous documentation supports the child-protection process, provides the treating team with a clear record, and protects the nurse legally. It also helps ensure the family is treated consistently by every clinician involved.